6 Best Jimmy John's Sauces of 2023 [Journey into Yum]

By: Shivani Choudhary
Updated On: September 18, 2023

Jimmy John's Sauces have dominated any conversation about fast-food condiments, sparking fierce debates and inspiring hard-core loyalty among food enthusiasts. Love for these flavorful elixirs often transcends the boundary of simple sandwich spreads to become an essential part of a culinary repertoire. It's their knack for transforming any humble dish into an extravaganza of flavors that has won over the hearts and taste buds of big and small sandwich lovers alike.

After plunging headfirst into the saucy world of Jimmy John's, I find myself eager to share my experiences, hoping that it inspires you to transform your next meal into a tantalizing journey of flavors.

Also Read: Best KFC Sauces Ranked

Article Includes

6 Best Jimmy John's Sauces Ranked As of 2023

Best Jimmy John's Sauces Ranked As of 2023

Jimmy John's is not just about fresh, fast, and scrumptious sandwiches; its wide array of signature sauces is also a world of flavors waiting to be unfurled. Here, I'll take you on a flavor-filled journey through six standout Jimmy John's sauces that have become my all-time favorites.

1. Jimmy John's Mustard Sauce: The Invigorating Kick

Jimmy’s Mustard - Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

Whenever I spot a smoky yellow color inside a sandwich, Jimmy’s Mustard is what my mind drifts towards. This condiment's distinct taste and texture landed it a prime place in my list of Jimmy John's exceptional sauces.

Jimmy’s Mustard delivers a punch of flavors from the get-go. You encounter a tartness that’s followed up with a gentle hint of spice on your tongue. The harmony and contrast between these flavors make the entire eating experience a musical symphony that dances on your palate.

It’s more than just a condiment, it’s a veritable elixir of robust taste that gives extraordinary depth to your sandwiches. Each spoonful of Jimmy’s Mustard is a masterclass in flavor balance. It neither overpowers nor dilutes the existing taste of your food. It simply adds a different dimension that makes an ordinary dish extraordinary.

Moreover, the classy essence of this mustard sauce, that's both spicy yet full of earthy goodness, makes it a great companion to the Italian Night Club sandwich or the Pepe. The potent kick of Jimmy’s Mustard beautifully punctuates the strong taste of Italian cold cuts in these sandwiches, elevating every bite to a whole new level.

The experience of Jimmy's Mustard, however, doesn't stop at sandwiches. I've also explored its potential with other dishes. A smear of it over a hotdog, a drizzle over my bowl of salad, or simply a side dip with my French fries, Jimmy's Mustard never ceased to amaze me with its versatility. It effortlessly enhances the food without slathering it in caloric excess.

The expansive flavor profile of Jimmy's Mustard, its ability to magically uplift dishes, and the underlining kick it provides will undoubtedly charm anyone who dares to experiment with their food. Simply put, Jimmy's Mustard is far more than a common condiment. It's a culinary revelation that demands to be sampled.

2. Jimmy John's Dijon Mustard Sauce: The Sophisticated Taste

Dijon Mustard - Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

After treating myself to the invigorating kick of regular mustard, I decided to stroll further into the flavorful world of Jimmy John's and came face to face with the Dijon Mustard. For those with a taste for the sophisticated and the exotic, the Dijon Mustard is tailor-made for you.

At first glance, the condiment promises a rich, gourmet experience. It strikes a perfect harmony between the rustic essence of mustard seeds and the tanginess of white wine vinegar. The amalgamation is nothing short of a piquant explosion on your taste buds. The tangy flavor, though prominent, is not overpowering. The mustard and vinegar balance each other out beautifully, providing a multi-dimensional taste experience.

The sophisticated allure of Dijon Mustard fits perfectly atop the Unwich or the Totally Tuna. The Dijon mustard lends a taste profile that dances between tangy and spicy, taking sandwich indulgence to a different level. Essentially, it adds an edge of luxurious taste, while simultaneously amplifying the inherent flavors of the sandwiches.

Beyond traditional sandwiches, Dijon Mustard has given me plenty of enticing food pairings. It seamlessly blends with the delicate flavor of salmon, takes the humble chicken breast up a notch, and infuses grilled vegetables with a delectable tanginess. Experimenting with this sauce never ends, as it does wonders even on salads or as a dipping sauce on a charcuterie platter.

The Dijon Mustard from Jimmy John's is not your average condiment. It brings together the best of both worlds - tang, and spice, offering a unique flavor perspective. It is sure to please even the most discerning eaters with its signature taste and proves itself an indispensable asset in enhancing the culinary journey.

Also Read: Best Shake Shack Sauces

3. Jimmy John's Horseradish Aioli Sauce: The Fiery Delight

Horseradish Aioli - Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

Next up on my journey of culinary exploration is Jimmy John's Horseradish Aioli - a condiment reserved exclusively for those willing to spice things up. This unique creation from Jimmy John's isn't for the faint-hearted.

The potency of the horseradish pairs flawlessly with the creamy goodness of aioli, resulting in a fiery delight that sends tingles down your palate. It’s like a sudden gust of wind on a hot summer day – completely unexpected, yet undeniably exhilarating.

I especially enjoyed it with the Gargantuan sandwich. The intense horseradish flavor amped up the bold blend of meats, making every bite an unforgettable explosion of flavors. The untamed flavors of the Horseradish Aioli made even a homely roast beef sandwich feel like a gourmet treat.

However, the adventure of flavors doesn’t stop at sandwiches. I've found the Horseradish Aioli to be equally pleasing when paired with grilled seafood or as a marinade for grilled steaks, as it lends an intoxicating piquancy that invigorates the senses.

Horseradish Aioli redefines the idea of what a condiment can offer. It takes you on a thrilling ride of flavors that does more than just complement a dish – it makes the dish come alive. This fiery delight is definitely a must-try for all spice enthusiasts out there who don’t mind a little adventure on their plate.

4. Jimmy John's Hellmann’s Mayonnaise Sauce: Celebrating Tradition

Hellmann’s Mayonnaise- Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

In the vast and diverse world of Jimmy John's sauces, Hellmann’s Mayonnaise represents a classic that needs no introduction. Far from being a mere sandwich dressing, this is a culinary staple that sings the ideal balance of sweetness, sourness, and a touch of unmistakable umami.

The creaminess of Hellmann’s Mayonnaise is unparalleled. Each dollop glistens with a promise of luscious richness, and every taste, creamy heaven. Enveloping this delightful texture, however, is a flavor profile that's subtle, yet distinct. You’ll get a hint of both sweet and sour - but what I consistently notice is a touch of umami that is often overlooked.

Convenience, versatility, and a taste that pairs seamlessly with countless recipes - this mayonnaise has them all. Whether it’s making my morning egg or tuna salad sandwich indulgent, or providing the perfect base for homemade dressings, Hellmann’s Mayonnaise never fails to enhance my culinary creations. It’s almost like having a secret miracle ingredient handy that can swiftly turn a mundane dish into an appetizing masterpiece.

5. Jimmy John's Ranch Sauce: The Creamy Elixir

Ranch Sauce- Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

Straight from the house of Jimmy John's, the beloved Ranch Sauce is a treat that brings joy to every sense. It's a masterpiece I found myself coming back to – time and time again – eager for another indulgent taste.

The Ranch Sauce is extraordinary in its simplicity. The creamy, velvety texture enchants the taste buds whilst establishing an enticing balance between the tanginess of buttermilk and the subdued sharpness of the vinegar. A spectacle of flavor that unfolds gradually as you delve deeper into each bite.

What appeals to me the most is how the Ranch Sauce adds depth and character to a dish. Its addition to my Turkey Tom or Vito stimulates the taste experience beyond my wildest dreams. Like a secret ingredient, it soothes the palate with its velvety texture while perking it up with its tangy notes.

My exploration of the Ranch Sauce didn't stop at sandwiches alone. I've used it on warm, freshly baked potatoes, crispy french fries, and crunchy salads. It is astonishing how an innocent dribble of Ranch Sauce can transform a mundane dish into a feisty culinary experience.

I discovered it to be more than a dipping sauce, it's an invitation to the rich, creamy world of Jimmy John's where the flavor comes to life. The Ranch Sauce, with its versatility and overpowering goodness, has secured a top spot on my list of favorites.

6. Jimmy John's Grey Poupon Sauce: The Gourmet Choice

Grey Poupon - Best Jimmy Johns Sauce

Closing my personal exploration of Jimmy John's sauces is the one that culminates the orchestra of all flavors, Grey Poupon. This experience was like meeting a dignified maestro who weaves an enchanting melody, knowing just when to hold back and when to take center stage.

Grey Poupon is a variant of Dijon Mustard, yet it manages to carve its unique identity. It's neither overpoweringly sharp as the typical yellow mustard nor the sophisticated kick of Dijon. Instead, it's the perfect blend of pleasurable pungency that harmonizes with an intricate, tangy sweetness, dancing close to the spicy end of the spectrum.

What truly sets Grey Poupon apart is its versatility. Whether it's elevating Jimmy John's Italian Night Club sandwich to the pinnacle of flavor, gracing over roast beef, or delicately brushing some on a ham and cheese croissant - the aromatic spice of Grey Poupon balances things out, never dominating, but always uplifting.

It’s like that finishing touch of elegance to your ensemble, that last brush stroke on your canvas, that final garnish on your plate. Grey Poupon is refinement personified, tying the knot to the wonderful journey of Jimmy John’s sauces that is sure to linger in your taste buds, leaving you yearning for more.

Also Read: Best Buffalo Wild Wings Sauces Ranked

How to Select the Perfect Jimmy John's Sauce for Your Sandwich?

Choosing the perfect sauce to complement your sandwich can be likened to culinary art. It's about understanding individual flavor profiles and how they can enhance the taste of the sandwich components.

Understanding the Flavor Profile

A vital step to selecting your sauce is understanding the flavor profile it will add to your sandwich. For instance, Jimmy’s Mustard packs a rich tartness followed by a subtle hint of spice. It invigorates the palate and works incredibly well to add zing to relatively milder sandwiches like the Italian Night Club or the Pepe.

For those seeking a bit of sophistication, the Dijon Mustard balances tangy with spicy, adding an elevated touch to any sandwich. Those looking for creamy comfort can rely on the Ranch sauce, whose buttermilk tanginess works like a charm with food as divergent as Turkey Tom and the Vito.

Pairing Sauces with Your Sandwich

If you're the adventurous type, Jimmy John's offers some fiery delights such as the Horseradish Aioli. This sauce, with its potent, zesty flavor, amps up sandwiches like the Gargantuan. The classic Hellmann’s Mayonnaise and slightly spicy Grey Poupon work well with virtually any sandwich, making them a solid choice for the unsure.

Why Jimmy John's Sauces Should Be Your Next Culinary Exploration?

Why Jimmy Johns Sauces Should Be Your Next Culinary Exploration?

If you're anything like me, food isn't merely about sustenance. It's about savoring different flavors, experimenting with textures, and indulging in a continually evolving sensory journey.

Unique Flavor Journey

Jimmy John's Sauces offer a unique journey of flavor exploration, each with its distinct palate profile, elevating the sandwich, or any dish for that matter, from ordinary to extraordinary. They allow divergence from the usual, enabling you to embark on a gourmet tour without stepping out of the comfort of your home.

Versatility in Cuisine

One of the hallmarks of these sauces, and a reason why I recommend them so heartily, is their versatility. Beyond sandwiches, they can be used as part of salad dressings, mixed into pasta, or as a flavorful addition to a meat marinade. Take the Horseradish Aioli; its zesty flavor makes it perfect not just for sandwiches, but it can liven up a seafood salad like no other.

So, whether you're a sandwich enthusiast or a culinary explorer, I wholeheartedly believe that Jimmy John's Sauces deserve to be a part of your kitchen lineup. They not only add that extra pizazz to your meals but also open up avenues to experiment with a variety of dishes. Happy Exploring!

How to Elevate Your Home Cooking with Jimmy John's Sauces?

Jimmy John's has long been renowned for its delicious sandwiches, and an integral part of their charm lies in their signature sauces. However, the power of these flavorful companions extends far beyond the sandwich sphere. Believe it or not, they have an uncanny ability to elevate your home cooking from good to gourmet.

Experiment with Marinades and Dressings

Jimmy John's Sauces serve as excellent bases for marinades and dressings. For example, the exceptional blend of Jimmy’s mustard and some olive oil transforms any simple salad into a flavorful side dish. It also marries well with chicken, providing an irresistible tanginess that permeates to make every bite unforgettable.

Similarly, the rich, creamy Ranch sauce makes for a delightfully refreshing dressing. It injects an instantaneous burst of zesty goodness when drizzled over a crisp green salad or serves as a dip for fried chicken, taking your taste buds on a wild culinary adventure.

Spice Up Everyday Dishes

The fiery Horseradish Aioli can take your regular mashed potatoes or steak to the next level, while the undertones of Dijon Mustard can provide a much-needed kick to your roasted vegetables. As they say, the details make the difference, and in cooking, it’s these minor tweaks that turn an ordinary dish into something special.

Why Jimmy John's Sauces are a Must-Have in Your Kitchen Pantry?

Why Jimmy Johns Sauces are a Must-Have in Your Kitchen Pantry?

Ever experienced the feeling of opening your kitchen cabinet and finding something missing? More often than not, it's the lack of variety in flavors. Jimmy John's sauces can quickly fill this void in your kitchen, as they cater to a diverse set of palates and add a dramatic richness to your dishes.

Catering to Various Taste Buds

One of the highlights of Jimmy John's sauces is their diverse range of flavors. Be it the distinct sharpness of Dijon mustard, the creamy satisfaction of Hellmann’s mayonnaise, or the tantalizing kick of Horseradish Aioli, there’s a sauce for everyone. Having them in your pantry ensures you’re always prepared to liven up your meals to every guests’ satisfaction.

Versatility in Use

The beauty of JJs sauces lies in their versatility. They can enhance a humble breakfast sandwich, transform your salads, add depth to your marinades, and deliver an enticing flavor to your main meals. Once you begin incorporating them into your home cooking, you’ll invariably find an essential spot for these flavorful additions.

Elevating your home cooking and ensuring a well-equipped pantry with rich flavors is a sure-shot way to bring joy to every meal. The next time you're looking to add a dash of extraordinary to your ordinary meals, don't forget to reach out for a jar of your favorite Jimmy John's sauce! So tell me, which of these sauces have you tried, or which ones are you eager to try now?

The Art of Pairing: How to Match Jimmy John's Sauces with Your Favorite Foods?

Whether you're using them to add some zing to morning scrambled eggs or to elevate a bowl of evening pasta, Jimmy John's Sauces are your best buddies. Each sauce brings a unique flavor and brings out the best in your food.

Jimmy’s Mustard

For me, the zesty yet slightly sweet flavor of Jimmy's Mustard performed magnificently with a toasted bagel, adding that additional spark to every bite.

Dijon Mustard

The elegance of Dijon Mustard, with its robust tangy undercurrent, has flawlessly complemented a perfectly grilled steak.

Ranch Sauce

If you're a fan of all things crispy, the Ranch Sauce with its tantalizing blend of sour, umami, and a bit of sweet, pairs brilliantly with a variety of salads and fried delights.

How Jimmy John's Sauces Transform an Ordinary Sandwich into Gourmet Delight?

How Jimmy Johns Sauces Transform an Ordinary Sandwich into Gourmet Delight?

Imagine your standard sandwich - it's delicious, nutritious even, but it tends to lack that special something that makes your taste buds dance. Well, introducing Jimmy John's Sauces to your humble sandwich can lead to an absolute party in your mouth.

Hellmann’s Mayonnaise

Take, for example, Hellmann's Mayonnaise. By simply introducing this creamy delight to your sandwich, you're adding a smooth, subtly tangy agent that binds the sandwich ingredients together and enhances the overall taste.

Horseradish Aioli

Consider the firework that is Horseradish Aioli. An application of this sauce to a roast beef sandwich not just brightens every bite but adds a new dimension to the experience.

And there you have it - your regular sandwich has now been transformed into a gastronomic extravaganza. The power of Jimmy John's Sauces cannot be underestimated, as their potential to revolutionize your meals is nothing short of spectacular. In the end, food, much like life, is all about the right combinations, and Jimmy John's sauces are here to ensure you find the perfect match.

The Jimmy John's Sauce That Matches Your Personality: Find Out How!

Ever considered the idea that your favorite Jimmy John's Sauce might reveal something about your personality? Our preferences, including our gastronomic ones, often reveal interesting aspects of our personalities. So, let's have a bit of fun and see what your choice of Jimmy John's Sauce says about you!

Jimmy’s Mustard

The choice of the adventurous and bold. If Jimmy’s Mustard is your go-to sauce, you're likely not afraid to dive headfirst into daunting situations and enjoy getting lost to find your way back. There's an infectious energy about you that others respect and admire.

Dijon Mustard

A sauce for the sophisticated soul. If you can't resist the slightly spicy and luxuriously smooth Dijon Mustard, you probably enjoy the fine things in life and treat everyday moments like grand events. You’re likely an individual who appreciates detail and is always admirably well-organized.

Ranch Sauce

Choosing the Ranch Sauce often signifies a balanced personality. You know when to have fun, and when to buckle down and work hard. Friends often look to you for reliable, practical advice. Comforting and laidback, you're the one people turn to in a crisis.

Horseradish Aioli

Horseradish Aioli is for those who dare to be different. You're not afraid to step away from what's conventional and have a flair for asserting your uniqueness and creativity. No challenge is too big for your determined spirit.

Hellmann’s Mayonnaise

Hellmann’s Mayonnaise lovers are eternally optimistic. You believe in the beauty of simplicity and find joy in life's little moments. You're genuine, and authentic, and your kindred spirit often brings comfort to everyone around you.

Grey Poupon

If you are a Grey Poupon fan, you are likely sophisticated with a twist, just like this mustard. You’ve got a charm that draws people in and an appreciation for the refined aspects of life, all while maintaining a unique perspective on things.

Remember, this is all in good jest! But next time you reach for that Jimmy John's Sauce to complement your meal, you just might catch yourself grinning at your saucy alternative ego!

Also Read: Best Sonic Sauces

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are Jimmy John's Sauces so popular?

Jimmy John's Sauces have garnered a loyal following due to their unique flavor profiles. Each sauce is carefully crafted with a balanced blend of ingredients, delivering a distinctive taste that enhances your sandwich experience. These sauces also serve a versatile role, complementing various dishes beyond sandwiches.

What is the most recommended Jimmy John's Sauce for beginners?

For those new to Jimmy John's Sauces, the Hellmann’s Mayonnaise is a safe and delicious starting point. Its creamy texture and balanced flavor palette can enhance any sandwich or salad, making it a universally loved condiment.

Can Jimmy John's Sauces be used in other dishes apart from sandwiches?

Absolutely! The versatility of Jimmy John's Sauces elevates it from merely being a sandwich spread. You can integrate these flavorful elixirs into various dishes like salads, wraps, or even as a dipping sauce. The Ranch Sauce, for instance, works beautifully with chicken wings.

What sandwich pairs best with the Horseradish Aioli?

The Gargantuan is my personal recommendation for the Horseradish Aioli. The zesty and potent flavor of the aioli works wonders with the variety of ingredients in the sandwich, taking it to a whole new level of deliciousness.

Is there a Jimmy John's Sauce that gives a gourmet experience?

Yes, the Grey Poupon, a variant of Dijon Mustard, embodies the taste and style of a refined gourmet experience. Its slightly spicy undertone imparts an exclusive grace to your sandwich, making each bite an unforgettable experience.

How can I buy Jimmy John's Sauces?

Jimmy John's Sauces can be directly ordered from the Jimmy John's website or purchased through popular online marketplaces such as Amazon. You may also find them in local supermarkets in the condiments aisle.


My venture into the world of Jimmy John's Sauces has undoubtedly left a tantalizing imprint on my palate that persists long after the last bite is devoured. Their unique ability to uplift the humblest of sandwiches and the grandest of meals cannot be downplayed. Each of these deliciously diverse sauces, from the subtly tangy Dijon Mustard to the fiery Horseradish Aioli, spoke their own flavorful language and added a distinct culinary signature to my meals.

As I revisit old favorites and discover newfound delicacies, I can't help but credit a generous part of my enjoyment to this kaleidoscope of sauces. Once pledged your allegiance to Jimmy John's Sauces, there is a good chance your culinary endeavors will never be the same again.

Food Lover and Storyteller 🍽️✨ With a fork in one hand and a pen in the other, Shivani brings her culinary adventures to life through evocative words and tantalizing tastes. Her love for food knows no bounds, and she's on a mission to share the magic of flavors with fellow enthusiasts.
Related Articles from the same category:
This a blog for Travellers & Travel Lovers
Copyright 2023 - All Rights Reserved.