20 Best Black Olives Ranked As of 2024 [Insider’s Picks]

There is a world of varied richness and depth hidden beneath the inky, glossy exterior of black olives. This small, often overlooked culinary delight has earned its rightful place in global cuisine due to its unique taste, versatility, and rich nutritional profile. Whether your preference is for pitted, stuffed, or sliced; whether they are the star of your pizza, the sly secret ingredient to your stew, or simply the garnish on your salad; the search for the best black olive is a delicious journey that takes you from the ordinary to the extraordinary!

Each variety of black olive has its own personality and distinctive flavor profile, presenting endless culinary possibilities and adventures. Whether you’re a seasoned olive connoisseur, or just starting your olive exploration journey, this guide will arm you with an insider’s perspective on choosing the best black olive.

Also Read: Best Baking Spices

20 Best Black Olives Ranked As of 2024

Exploring the vibrant world of black olives is like embarking on an exciting culinary journey across the globe. With so many delicious options to choose from, finding the best black olive can be an adventure in itself. Come along as we delve into an array of exquisite flavors with our top 20 picks, your passport to a world of amazing black olives.

1. Market Pantry Small Pitted Ripe Olives

The first time I tasted the Market Pantry Small Pitted Ripe Olives, the depth of flavor took me by surprise. On opening the can, you’re greeted with these small, almost delicate olives, shimmering in their natural brine. Despite their size, they pack a flavorful punch that leaves you wanting more.

The joy of these olives is their bite-sized consistency. They’re meticulously pitted, eliminating the risk of an unexpected crunch. Handpicked and preserved in a light salt brine, they maintain their natural flavor and unique texture. You can taste the sunshine that bathed each olive, reminiscent of old-world olive groves.

Their versatile size lends them as a delightful addition to your salads or pizzas, and even works wonders in a tapenade. Appetizers like Spanish tapas or Greek mezze shine with these small wonders, their subtle flavor balancing the robust ingredients. Add them to your pasta dishes, and they hold their own, enhancing not just the aesthetics of the dish, but also its taste profile.

The Market Pantry Small Pitted Ripe Olives are an excellent product, reflecting the brand’s commitment to quality and affordability. Whether you are rustling up a quick weekday meal, or hosting a grand party, this humble ingredient can star in your menu.

2. Early California Large Pitted Black Olives

The Early California Large Pitted Black Olives serve a gorgeous blend of size and taste. The moment you first lay eyes on these, you’d be looking at black, sizable, consistent beauties. Not just visually appealing, they transform an ordinary dish into a symphony of flavors and textures.

The olives are handpicked at their prime and submerged in a lightly salted brine, preserving their natural, earthy flavor. The end result is an olive that is bold, not overpowering, but mellow, enhancing the overall taste of your dishes. I found it to be a contrasting mix of slightly bitter yet subtly sweet, a hint of the perfect sun-ripened olive.

These large pitted black olives stand out magnificently in Italian recipes like Chicken Cacciatore or Greek salads. The robust size makes them an ideal stuffing candidate, with capers, cheeses, or sundried tomatoes. Add these whole to your martinis, and you’re elevated to a complete new level of class and sophistication.

There’s a timeless charm about the Early California Large Pitted Black Olives. The product stands testament to the brand’s heritage and its mission to deliver high-quality foods. When cooking with these olives, they not only stand out in your dishes, but they subtly blend in, enhancing the overall experience, delivering a meal that tastes exactly like the Mediterranean. Truly, a delightful pick!

3. 365 Whole Foods

As a fan of whole foods striving to incorporate them into my everyday meals, the 365 Whole Foods black olives were a must-try for me. The brand prides itself on offering organic products that uplift the flavors of your dishes while keeping health at the forefront. These black olives are indeed an embodiment of the brand’s core values.

Upon opening, you’ll find plump, glossy black olives bathed in a minimalistic brine, their flavor stark and distinguished. Their texture is firm yet juicy, and the taste profile beautifully balanced – not too salty, just the right hint of bitterness, and an underlying sweetness. What stood out to me was their natural, earthy flavor, a testament to the quality of olives used.

I loved using them in my salads and pasta. You can slice them, dice them, whip up a delicious Tapenade, or even munch them as is. These versatile black olives heighten the flavor of your dishes, without undermining their freshness. If there’s an olive that can bring out the passionate cook in you, it’s the 365 Whole Foods Black Olives.

4. Marmarabirlik Exclusive Black Olives

When I first laid my hands on the Marmarabirlik Exclusive Black Olives, I knew it was no ordinary product. The Marmarabirlik brand is renowned for its distinctly superior olives, and these black olives are a shining example of their commitment to uncompromised quality.

These olives go through an organic fermentation process that helps conserve their natural aroma and distinct taste. Additionally, they undergo a special screening and selection process, ensuring that only the finest olives reach your table. The flavor profile greets you with a unique, slightly bitter texture, enhanced with a defined saltiness and a touch of olive oil richness.

The distinct size, texture, and taste make them perfect for gourmet recipes. They blend in well with artisanal cheeses, subtle wines, and slow-cooked Mediterranean meals. A salad or pasta adorned with these olives becomes an instant gourmet dish. Marmarabirlik Exclusive Black Olives unarguably elevate your culinary experience, even on the most common of days.

5. DeLallo Large Ripe Pitted Black Olives

DeLallo Large Ripe Pitted Black Olives came across as a symphony of rich flavor and delightful texture. As an ardent olive lover, I was instantly drawn towards the bold size and the glossy black appearance of these olives. They are of excellent quality – each olive carefully hand-picked and perfectly pitted.

Coming from the house of DeLallo, a brand with deep Italian roots, these olives carry an undeniable Mediterranean charm. The flavor is ignited by a slightly tangy taste that offsets the inherent bitterness. Their distinct saltiness beautifully compliments the other components of your dish, enhancing its overall taste.

These olives are best enjoyed when served with a platter of assorted cheeses, lavishly spread over pizzas, or artfully tossed in salads – each bite you take will be an ode to the traditional Italian food. The rich, briny flavor of DeLallo Large Ripe Pitted Black Olives has the potential to awaken an epicurean in you. Not just a topping or a side, they are sure to steal the spotlight in every dish they go into. Simply irresistible!

6. Great Value Medium Black Olives

As I ventured into the world of olives, one brand I found that managed to maintain the perfect balance between quality and affordability was Great Value Medium Black Olives. This can of olives turned out to be one of the most budget-friendly options that did not compromise taste or quality.

Upon opening the can, I discovered olives of a harmonious size, possessing a rich, dark tone. Their glossy exterior skillfully preserved the moist, mildly briny interior, rendering a delightful bite. The saltiness was controlled, letting the inherent olive flavor be the hero.

Be it tapenades, salads, pizzas, or Mediterranean appetizers; these black olives seamlessly made their way into different dishes. I found them to be an easy solution to elevate my everyday meals without going heavy on the pocket. In my opinion, these olives prove that you don’t have to splurge to enjoy flavorful delicacies at home.

7. Pearls Sliced Black Olives

There’s a different kind of comfort that comes with pre-sliced ingredients, and Pearls Sliced Black Olives are no exception. Perfect for the indulgent yet time-pressed home chef, these pre-sliced olives make an excellent addition to your pantry.

As I opened the can, neat rows of uniformly sliced black olives greeted me. Each piece retained a fine, firm texture, managing to keep the flavors intact. Pearls sliced black olives are amazing! The taste was on the subtle side – not too pungent, but with just the right amount of brininess.

The best part? I put them to use across a variety of dishes – from classic salads, driving exotic flavors in enchiladas, or lending a crunch to my pizzas. Pearls Black Olives are no doubt a purposeful upgrade, ensuring no compromise on taste or time in the kitchen.

8. Sunfood Superfoods Organic Raw Olives

My quest for the best black olive wouldn’t be complete without embracing the organic route. When it came to Sunfood Superfoods Organic Raw Olives, I found a product that combines health and flavor beautifully. Bearing the hallmark of a trusted organic label, these olives were a splendid find indeed.

What struck me initially about these olives was their deep, luxurious color and robust size. Biting into them, I encountered a crisp texture housing a harmonious blend of pure, earthy flavors. A testament to their organic origin.

These were the perfect addition to my health-forward salads, giving them an extra burst of flavor. I loved that they’re free from pesticides, artificial flavors, and canned in pure water, staying true to natural organic standards. If you’re looking for a heart-healthy snack or a zingy addition to your recipes, Sunfood Superfoods Organic Raw Olives are your best bet.

9. Happy Belly Medium Ripe Pitted Black Olives

A unique find in my explorations was the Happy Belly Medium Ripe Pitted Black Olives. As the brand suggests, these olives are surely a happy addition to any belly, especially those who adore rich textures and well-rounded flavors.

Bracing the can’s pop, I found juicy delights shining like dark pearls. Their medium size captured an exquisite balance of juiciness and bite. What made Happy Belly olives an exciting discovery was their texture – firm, yet tender to the bite, and the taste – a subtlety of brininess that lets the natural savoriness simmer through.

Whether you want to jazz up your salads, amp up a pasta dish, or simply nibble on them as a nutritious snack, these olives can do it all. They were handy and a joy to use in my culinary adventures.

10. Lindsay Extra Large Black Olives

When it says ‘extra-large’ on a can of Lindsay olives, it means it. These olives are a memorable manifestation of the adage, “size does matter”. They were a statement on their own, so big that they demanded attention, and boy, did they have mine!

Rolling out from can to plate, the Lindsay Extra Large Black Olives dominated my appetizer platter effortlessly. The generous size was allied with an intense, briny flavor, which was followed by a distinctive sweetness that only black ripe olives possess. The velvety texture complementing the taste made the overall experience a memorable affair.

They were equally thrilling whether stuffed with peppers for a cocktail snack, sliced into rings for a pizza topping, or just popped straight in your mouth. They’ve earned a permanent spot in my pantry and my heart!

Also Read: Best Saltine Crackers

11. Mario Large Pitted Black Olives

Then came the real deal, the Mario Large Pitted Black Olives. They were like the epitome of what I imagined the perfect olive to taste like – balanced, supple, and all-around delicious.

Through the can’s narrow mouth, large, pitted delights rolled out, each one glossy as if winkling under the Mediterranean sun. The olives possessed a firm texture that held up well in myriad dishes. With a balanced brininess, they highlighted a beautifully mellow flavor, which subtly whispered notes of earthiness, captured naturally.

Whether it was about bringing an edge to the humble salad or a fun twist to pizza toppings, I found that Mario large pitted black olives stepped up to the plate each time with aplomb. Their versatility made them an instant hit in my kitchen!

12. Mediterranean Organic Black Olives Pitted

Next on my culinary journey was the Mediterranean Organic Black Olives Pitted. These black gems are harvested at the perfect moment of ripeness and cured to allow their full, naturally rich flavor to emerge. The heartiness and robust zest of these olives are truly remarkable.

Upon opening the jar, the sight that met my eyes was absolutely delightful. Each olive was black as ink, with a lustrous sheen that seemed to capture the Mediterranean sun’s warmth. The texture, too, sold me on these olives – firm yet yielding, with a softness that hinted at the fleshy consistency within. They’re really the perfect addition to any dish, adding their mellow, naturally briny tang that pairs so well with heartier notes.

But what stood out about these olives is their commitment to being organically grown. The effort and care taken in its cultivation are evident in its taste, which is clean and unadulterated. These olives have become a favorite in my recipes.

13. Sprouts Medium Ripe Pitted Black Olives

The Sprouts Medium Ripe Pitted Black Olives were a surprising discovery. These mid-sized beauties turned out to be the underdog that could. The olives are firm and meaty and have a sweet, tangy flavor—overall, an absolute joy to bite into. The pit is removed, adding to the convenience.

A can of these medium-sized black olives is not just a can of olives but a can of possibilities. They’re great on pizzas, tossed into salads, or baked into a loaf of rustic bread—their flavor profiles lift every dish up. Their fresh taste and well-balanced flavors make them a suitable choice for classic olive-based dishes and new forays into the culinary realm.

14. Del Monte Black Sliced Olives

Del Monte was a familiar face in my search. Known for a long-standing tradition of quality, their Black Sliced Olives did not disappoint. Pre-sliced, these olives save plenty of time in the kitchen, allowing me to focus on crafting a delicious meal.

These sliced black olives are tender and light with a slightly smoky flavor, a culinary chameleon that adapts to the nuances of any meal you prepare. They’re particularly wonderful when used in pizzas, pasta, or greek salads—their distinct tang plays well against the creaminess of cheese and richness of meats.

Del Monte’s black sliced olives win, particularly in the convenience department. No need to pit or slice – just open the can, drain them, and they’re ready to elevate your dishes.

15. Lindsay Organic Sliced Black Olives

Seeking a healthier, more environmentally-friendly option, my search led me to Lindsay Organic Sliced Black Olives. These USDA Certified organic olives are an answer to the rising demand for organically grown food. Their taste, far from being compromised, far exceeded my expectations.

Upon tasting, I was met with a smooth, slightly smoky flavor that reminded me of a cool evening by a mediterranean beach. This variety, whilst being delicious, serves a function too–they’re pre-sliced, a boon when prepping a meal that requires precision and speed. Both in terms of flavor and convenience, Lindsay’s organic sliced black olives have been a game changer in my kitchen.

I’ve found that these are particularly delightful when tossed in a salad, incorporated in a meat dish, or simply served as part of a cheese platter. An absolute must-try for those on the lookout for a robust yet versatile black olive.

16. K3 Masala Black Olives Sliced

Take a detour from conventional flavored olives and step into the world of K3 Masala Black Olives Sliced. An exciting blend of traditional Indian spices with ripe, luscious black olives, these are a treat for the taste buds.

Each bite is a symphony of flavor, from zesty and tangy, to sweet and slightly bitter. They are pre-sliced, which adds a level of convenience that cannot be overlooked in today’s busy life. The spice blends in splendid harmony with the olives’ natural flavors, transforming even a simple meal into an exotic dining experience.

These olives make an excellent topping for pizza or a stuffing for bread. They also pair well with grilled meats and vegetables, creating a delectably unique fusion of flavors.

17. Pearls Ripe Pitted Large Black Olives

It’s rare to find an olive that combines size, taste and ease of use quite like the Pearls Ripe Pitted Large Black Olives. These generously sized black olives exhibit a perfect balance of firmness and juiciness, staying true to their ripe and plump promise.

The taste is marvelously full-bodied, with just the right balance of salty, tangy, and bitter notes. The pitting adds such convenience, making these Robusto-sized olives a perfect fit for stuffing.

What really stands out is their versatility. They are perfect for tapenade, pair wonderfully with cheeses and wines, and can even stand-alone as an elegant hors d’oeuvre. No doubt about it, Pearls Ripe Pitted Large Black Olives have found a permanent place in my pantry.

18. Fragata Pitted Black Olives

When I first came across the Fragata Pitted Black Olives, I was intrigued. They hail from Spain, a country known for its luxurious olive varieties, and are pitted to add convenience. A single taste was all it took to have me convinced of their fine quality.

These dark, luscious beauties have a smooth, slightly sweet taste with an undertone of nuttiness that’s almost almond-like. The unforgettable taste isn’t the only selling point though, the texture is equally impressive – firm yet tender, almost melting on the tongue. Truly, a culinary experience like no other.

Whether tossed into salads, added to paella, or enjoyed with a glass of fine Spanish wine, these olives add a touch of exotic, sophisticated flavor to any dish. An absolute must-try for the true olive aficionado!

19. Krinos Foods Moroccan Dry Olive Oil Cured Black Olives

There is something enchanting about the Krinos Foods Moroccan Dry Olive Oil Cured Black Olives. Originating from the sun-drenched locales of the North African coastline, they bring a taste of the exotic to every dish.

The curing process, unique to this region, results in a distinct, rich and dense flavor – a transformative experience for your palate. They are somewhat shriveled, soaked in olive oil, and their taste is quite concentrated, providing a delightful culinary adventure with each bite.

Whether it is in a tagine, a stew, or a mezze platter, these olives add a uniquely North African touch. They’re worth the rave reviews and the occasional splurge. If you haven’t yet, give them a whirl. You won’t regret it.

20. Pearls Organic Black Olives

Last but certainly not least, the Pearls Organic Black Olives are a quality choice for fans of organic food items. They are foundationally robust, flavorful, and sourced from certified organic farms, ensuring they’re free from pesticides and harmful chemicals.

A versatile choice, they are ready to add that gourmet feel to your dishes, whether you’re creating a classic olive tapenade or bringing a twist to your homemade pizza. Getting these olives amounts to an investment in health, as they pack a powerful punch of antioxidants with no compromise on flavor.

From their environmentally-friendly footprint to their terrific taste, these olives are a wonderful addition to any pantry. As my journey in the quest for the best black olive continues, the Pearls Organic Black Olives remain a constant and enjoyable companion.

How To Decipher the Olive Label: Pitted Vs. Non-Pitted

When it comes to the great debate of pitted versus non-pitted olives, the choice can often seem overwhelming. In reality, deciphering the labels on olive cans and jars is a simple matter, and here’s how you can do it.

Pitted olives, as the name suggests, are olives with the pit or stone removed. They are often found across grocery aisles in jars and cans, and are a popular choice for recipes that require a smooth texture—think pizza toppings, pasta dishes, or tapenades. On the label, terms like pitted, seedless, or stoned indicate that the olive pits have been removed.

On the other hand, non-pitted olives or whole olives are olives that still contain the pit. These are a common choice for olive lovers who enjoy the slightly firmer texture and the full flavor that comes with the pit. They’re also popular as finger foods and decorative garnish, and are usually labelled simply as whole.

If the olives are sliced, that will also be indicated on the label. Sliced olives are convenient for quick cooking and making salads.

Let’s not forget stuffed olives, which are usually pitted olives filled with ingredients like pimientos, garlic, or cheese. The stuffing will be mentioned on the label. Knowing these terminologies will allow you to choose the best black olives tailored to your specific culinary needs.

Understanding the Health Benefits of Black Olives: Why It’s Good for You

The dark-hued, glossy black olives we adore are not just a delicious addition to our meals but they also come packed with numerous health benefits.

1. High in Antioxidants: Black Olives are known to contain a variety of antioxidants like vitamin E and oleuropein, which can protect the body against oxidative stress and inflammation. Antioxidants are essential to keep our cells healthy and ward off diseases.
2. Heart-healthy fats: Black olives are a rich source of monounsaturated fats, which are known as the heart-healthy fats. These fats can reduce the levels of bad cholesterol and maintain heart health. Thus, black olives are a tasty way to keep your heart in good shape!
3. Rich in Iron: Just about 3.5 ounces of black olives provide around 3.3 mg of iron, which is essential for the production of red blood cells and the maintenance of a strong immune system.
4. Good for Eye Health: Thanks to the presence of Vitamin A, black olives can contribute to the maintenance of good eye health and vision.
5. Bone Health: Olive oil, made from black olives, has been found to improve bone health according to certain studies. This is attributed to the presence of polyphenols in olives.

Including black olives in your diet can be a delicious way to contribute to your overall health and wellness. Remember, moderation is key, as olives are high in sodium due to the curing process they undergo.

Exploring the Different Varieties of Black Olives: A Guide for Beginners

The world of black olives is wonderfully diverse, each variety bearing a fascinating history, unique cultivation process, and a distinct flavor profile. Let’s explore some of the more beloved varieties.

1. Market Pantry Small Pitted Ripe Olives: Small but bursting with bold, intense flavor – they easily enhance any dish.
2. Mario Large Pitted Black Olives: Direct from Italy, these olives bring an undeniably authentic taste of the Mediterranean colors to any culinary affair.
3. Mediterranean Organic Black Olives Pitted: Organically grown and meticulously harvested in the sun-drenched Mediterranean isles, these black gems are distinctly flavorful and nutrient-dense.
4. PEARLS Organic Black Olives: A palate pleaser, these organic olives offer a rich, smooth texture, making them a delicious addition to any salad, pizza or pasta.
5. Krinos Foods Moroccan Dry Olive Oil Cured Black Olives: From the balmy coasts of North Africa, these olives are dry-cured and steeped in olive oil, resulting in a uniquely rich, tangy flavor.
6. 365 Whole Foods: These whole olives are a paradox of flavors – mildly tangy, moderately salty and subtly sweet, making them a versatile ingredient in a variety of dishes.

Remember, exploring the diverse world of black olives is a process. You might not fall in love with the first variety you taste, but worry not. This culinary journey is about experiencing and savoring the plethora of flavors and textures on the global olive pallet!

How to Store Black Olives: Practical Tips for Olive Lovers

The key to enjoying your favorite black olives at their optimal flavor is in the storage. Here are my tried-and-true tips for keeping your olives fresh and delicious.

1. Always refrigerate after opening: Once the can or jar is opened, transfer the olives along with the brine into an airtight glass or plastic container and store in the refrigerator. The brine helps retain the flavor and texture.
2. Don’t remove the pit: Unpitted olives last longer as the pit protects the inner flesh from exposure to air, preventing oxidation.
3. Oil can be your ally: Storing olives in olive oil helps preserve their flavor and texture (especially important if the olives are dry-cured).
4. Use within two weeks: To enjoy the best taste and quality, aim to consume the olives within two weeks of opening the jar.
5. Olives and Freezing? While it’s possible to freeze black olives, the freezing and defrosting process can compromise the texture making them a bit mushy. Use frozen olives promptly after defrosting and within three months for the best quality.

When it boils down, good olive storage is largely about where you store them (in the fridge), what you store them with (their own brine, or oil), and how quickly you use them up (as soon as you can after opening!). Fresh, flavorful olives can truly elevate any dish, making the culinary experience a memorable one.

Also Read: Best Manuka Honey Brands

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

So there you have it – a deep dive into the world of black olives. Each variety with its distinct taste and texture brings something unique to your plate. The adventure to discover the best black olive may be an ongoing journey, but it’s certainly a savory and delightful one. Now that you’re equipped with insights into some of the top choices, it’s time to turn those can opening skills into gourmet decision-making.

Let your taste buds lead the way and remember, whether on pizza, in salads, or as a stand-alone snack, the joy of savoring black olives lies as much in the eating as it does in the choosing. Happy olive hunting!