Sixstoreys Logo

Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe for Timeless Enjoyment

By: Aman Babal
Updated On: May 28, 2024

Welcome, dear readers, to the classic realm of mixology where tradition meets taste. Waiting eagerly to be poured into the heart of your exquisite glassware is the timeless delight known as the old fashioned cocktail. Reputed for its smooth bourbon, tingling bitters, and sweet undertones amicably merged in an elegant dance of flavors, it has charmed many a patron at renowned bars across America. Today, we’re pulling out all the stops to reveal an authentic old fashioned cocktail recipe, designed to help you stir up this classic libation right within the cozy confines of your own home. Be ready to experience the sublime pleasure of crafting this iconic cocktail, as I walk you through each step of making and savoring it exactly the way you like!

Also Read: Easy and Delicious Manhattan Cocktail Recipe

Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe

A Glimpse Into The History of the Old Fashioned Cocktail

The Old Fashioned, in all its robust and elegant glory, is a cocktail of profound historical significance. The term ‘cocktail’ first appeared in print in 1806 in an American publication, defined as a stimulating beverage made from spirits of any kind, sugar, water, and bitters. The Old Fashioned cocktail fit this description perfectly, and despite its simplicity, won over hearts with staggering speed.

In the early 19th century, a cocktail denoted a specific type of drink. The recipe for this classic libation is believed to have originated at The Pendennis Club, a gentlemen’s club in Louisville, Kentucky. The cocktail was famously made by a bartender in honor of Colonel James E. Pepper, a prominent bourbon distiller, who then introduced it to the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in New York City. From there, the Old Fashioned cocktail grew in popularity, its timelessness resonating with generations of discerning drinkers.

What Makes an Old Fashioned Cocktail So Special?

There’s an undeniable magic to the Old Fashioned cocktail that has garnered it an enduring status in the cocktail world. But what exactly makes it so special? For starters, the simplicity of its composition gives each element a moment to shine. The sweetness of the sugar, bitter notes from the bitters, the heat of the bourbon, all tied together with a slice of orange peel or a cherry garnish.

Then, there is the ritual aspect. Making an Old Fashioned is a bit like a slow dance. It’s not a cocktail you rush – it’s about taking the time to muddle, to stir, to taste. It truly is a labor of love.

The Old Fashioned is also a versatile cocktail. Although traditionally prepared with whiskey, you can substitute your spirit of choice. Whether you enjoy it with bourbon, rye, or even dark rum, it changes the taste and texture of the cocktail, making it a personalized experience.

The timeless appeal in an era where classic cocktails are having a renaissance, the Old Fashioned remains true to its origins and yet can be played with to fit modern tastes. That is what makes this cocktail not old-fashioned but, indeed, ever-fashionable!

Finally, the experience of an Old Fashioned cocktail goes beyond the taste alone. I can’t help but quote Mark Twain here, “Too much of anything is bad, but too much of good whiskey is barely enough.” This rings true especially when savoring the Old Fashioned cocktail. It is the anticipation of the first sip, the aroma escaping the glass as it hits your senses, the chill of the glass in your hand, and then – the taste. The bold, warm, and subtly sweet flavors of the cocktail explode onto your palate in glorious harmony, making each sip a moment to remember.

Also Read: Best Rums For Cocktails

Gathering Your Ingredients for the Perfect Old Fashioned Cocktail

The magic of the Old Fashioned lies in the perfect blend of its simple yet powerful ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need:

  • Bourbon Whiskey: A good quality bourbon is crucial. The depth and flavor of this whiskey are what makes your cocktail stand out. Might I suggest something in the lines of Buffalo Trace, a classic favorite?
  • Bitters: The traditional choice here is Angostura Bitters, which provides the signature aroma and flavor.
  • Sugar: A lump of sugar or a teaspoon of sugar syrup adds sweetness that balances out the strength of the bourbon and the bitters.
  • Water: A splash, just enough to dissolve the sugar.
  • Garnish: A twist of fresh orange peel and a maraschino cherry.

Choosing the Right Glassware for Your Old Fashioned Cocktail

The Old Fashioned cocktail not only tastes classic but should look classic too. And the right glassware is crucial in making that happen.

A typical old-fashioned glass – often referred to as a rocks glass – is the perfect choice here. Its wide brim and sturdy base are ideal for muddling your sugar and bitters and for accommodating that large ice cube. Plus, there’s something undeniably sophisticated about sipping a bold cocktail from a hefty, elegant rocks glass.

Mixing the Cocktail: A Step-by-Step Guide

The beauty of the Old Fashioned cocktail lies in its simplicity. Here’s a detailed guide:

  1. Muddling the Sugar and Bitters: In your rocks glass, add a lump of sugar, a dash of water, and two or three dashes of bitters. Use a muddler or the back of a spoon to combine and crush the sugar until dissolved.
  2. Add Ice: In goes a large ice cube. The size is important; a larger cube melts slower, avoiding excessive dilution.
  3. Pour the Bourbon: Now it’s time to pour 2 oz of your chosen bourbon whiskey.
  4. Garnish: Twist the orange peel over the top of the drink to release the oils. Drop it into the glass, along with a maraschino cherry.
  5. Stir and Serve: Give it a gentle stir, and your cocktail is ready to be savored.

The Perfect Pair: What Food Goes Best with an Old Fashioned Cocktail

When it comes to pairing food with an Old Fashioned cocktail, you want to consider dishes with robust, hearty flavors. This classic cocktail, with its keynotes of whisky and sweetness, pairs beautifully with grilled meats. A juicy steak or a good slab of barbecue ribs can create a perfect counterbalance with the cocktail’s sweet and spicy notes.

Cheese platters can also be a wonderful choice, as the creamy and salty flavors of cheese can brilliantly cut through the cocktail’s sweetness. If you’re into seafood, try smoked salmon; its oily richness will mesh well with the drink’s smoothness.

For the end of the meal, try rich chocolates or flaky pastries with bourbon-infused fillings. The caramel and vanilla notes in the drink will enhance these desserts, making the pairing the ultimate indulgence.

Also Read: Best Creme De Menthe Cocktails

Pro Tip: Adding Your Personal Touch

Every good bartender knows that a cocktail isn’t just a recipe, but an expression of the one who made it. So, why not add your personal touch to the Old Fashioned?

Should you prefer a sweeter drink, you might substitute traditional sugar for flavorful alternatives like honey or maple syrup. When it comes to selecting the bitters, feel free to experiment with different types and brands. Each imparts unique flavor characteristics that can dramatically alter your drink.

As for garnishes, feel free to think outside the box. While an orange peel and cherry are the classic choices, a lemon peel or a splash of cherry juice can add a new twist.

Just remember, the essence of creating an Old Fashioned cocktail is to find the perfect balance. So, in adding your personal touch, be cautious not to overpower the whisky, which should remain the star of the show.

Nothing is etched in stone. Don’t be afraid to tweak your Old Fashioned cocktail recipe to suit your taste. Embrace the role of the home mixologist and let your creativity soar! In no time, you’ll be serving Old Fashioneds that not only impress your guests but also tell your unique tale!

Beverage Explorer and Tastemaker ???????????? Aman's quest for liquid delights knows no limits. From hoppy brews to aged spirits, he uncovers the tales behind each sip. His eloquent descriptions and accessible insights make every drink an adventure worth raising a glass to.
Related Articles from the same category:
This is a blog for Travellers & Travel Lovers
Copyright 2023 - All Rights Reserved.