Sixstoreys Logo

19 Weird Ice Cream Flavors [2024‘s Scoop on Strange]

By: Shivani Choudhary
Updated On: January 9, 2024

Let’s take a twisty ride through the vast universe of frozen delicacies! There’s no denying our outright love affair with ice cream–those ever-familiar flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry have become etched in our hearts over time we’ve got a scoopful of comfort waiting at the end of a cone. But as our gastronomic horizons expand wider than ever, we’re starting to see some truly weird ice cream flavors taking center stage.

From mouthwatering turkey to fiery hot sriracha, these icy oddities redefine the way we treat our taste buds. It’s time to dig in and unearth some frozen creations that will deeply challenge your idea of what belongs in ice cream, and possibly even entice you into taking a bite! So let’s brace our culinary spirit for a journey to the wild side as we delve into an eccentric world of ice cream beyond your wildest dreams.

Also Read: Best Tillamook Ice Cream Flavors

Article Includes

19 Weird Ice Cream Flavors of 2024

Weird Ice Cream Flavors of 2024

Ice cream is an undeniably beloved dessert worldwide, soothing our tongues on hot summer days, and cheering us up when we’re down. But beyond the classic, well-known favorites like chocolate and vanilla, a whole realm of weird and wacky ice cream flavors exists that are far from mundane and usual! From pizza to pickles, these novel flavors serve as a testament to human creativity in the culinary world and our ceaseless exploration for new taste sensations.

1. Thanksgiving Dinner from The Ice Cream Store

Thanksgiving Dinner from The Ice Cream Store - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

As you might have guessed from its name, this unique flavor serves all the delight of a Thanksgiving feast, but with an icy twist! Upon the first spoonful, you’ll be greeted with a burst of cranberry, morphing into tender turkey and savory stuffing. The sweet-salty contrast keeps your taste buds guessing and wanting more. You might even find bits of sweet potato and delectable roasted vegetables mixed in for a fully-rounded feast. As unusual as it may sound, this ice cream takes the essence of a family gathering and weaves it into a strangely addictive flavor that will leave you yearning for seconds.

2. Pizza-flavored Ice Cream

Pizza-flavored Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

To all the Pizza enthusiasts who can’t get enough of that cheesy, saucy goodness – this one’s for you! Pizza-flavored ice cream is the ultimate blend of two of America’s favorite foods. With tomato, basil, oregano, and garlic folded into a rich, creamy base, every lick delivers an unfamiliar sensation akin to biting into a slice of pizza; yet, it’s undeniably ice cream. And yes, it may take a few tries to fall in love with it, but once you do, there’s no going back! Each scoop allows you to explore both the realms of traditional and innovative food craftsmanship, making for an unforgettable experience.

3. Cicada Ice Cream

Cicada Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

When the delightful harmony of sweet and creamy meets the unmistakable crunch of insects, you get Cicada Ice Cream. Sound unsettling? Hang on a bit! In many parts of the world, eating insects is common practice. Cicadas, when blanched and coated in brown sugar and chocolate, mesh surprisingly well with the creamy ice cream base. The first taste might be startling, but some adventurous foodies report a distinct nutty flavor that is rather enjoyable. So if you’re someone who boldly accepts gastronomic challenges, Cicada Ice Cream can be a unique culinary adventure you might wish to embark on.

4. “Horse Flesh” Ice Cream

“Horse Flesh” Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Horse Flesh Ice Cream, despite its undeniably shocking name, is a trendy flavor in Japan and no, it doesn’t contain any horse flesh. Instead, this ice cream gets its surprising richness from a soy-based sauce that mimics the umami flavor of horse meat. The rich, savory flavor is a far cry from the sweet, creamy ice cream we’re accustomed to, but for those who love breaking norms, Horse Flesh Ice Cream is worth a dip. It is a one-of-a-kind flavor that inspires curiosity and dares you to explore new taste boundaries.

5. Strawberry Balsamic from Sweet Action Ice Cream

Strawberry Balsamic from Sweet Action Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

The name “Strawberry Balsamic” might sound more like a salad dressing to you. But, this ice cream flavor from Sweet Action Ice Cream will sweep you off your feet. The vibrancy of strawberries superbly matches with the tangy notes of balsamic vinegar to create a sweet yet acidic flavor profile. With each bite, you can taste the tartness of the balsamic vinegar, followed by the sweetness of the strawberries, for a pleasant contrast on your palate. If you’re looking to explore strange yet delightful ice cream flavors, Strawberry Balsamic is worth considering.

6. Chili Peppermint Ice Cream

Chili Peppermint Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Just by hearing its name, you can imagine the flavorful whirlwind of Chili Peppermint Ice Cream. On the one hand, it presents the chilling freshness of peppermint. On the other, it offers a scorching array of chilies that stings the back of your throat. Together, these flavors work surprisingly well. The initial lick is a frosty blast, followed by the creeping sensation of spice that warms you from the inside. It might feel like a challenge eating it, but the flavor offers a unique thrill that can be quite addicting.

7. Foie Gras Ice Cream

Foie Gras Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

The luxury item that once got its fame in restaurants has now made its appearance in the dessert world- Foie Gras Ice Cream. The idea of mixing the rich and buttery taste of foie gras with ice cream may sound unusual, but the result is a creamy marvel that’s likely to leave you licking your lips. The ice cream carries a unique savoriness, but don’t be fooled, it also brings out an unexpected sweetness. If you want to indulge in some luxury on a cone, Foie Gras Ice Cream is worth a shot.

8. Pink Lemonade Pop Rocks from Max & Mina’s Ice Cream

Pink Lemonade Pop Rocks from Max & Mina’s Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

The dreamy nostalgia of pop rocks meets the frosty delight of pink lemonade to create a zesty, bubbly masterpiece. The zing of Pink Lemonade is punctuated by the surprising crackle from Pop Rocks, providing memorable bursts of fun in every icy scoop. The fun element of pop rocks mixed with the tangy flavor of pink lemonade creates an exciting combination that’s just as enjoyable for adults as it is for children. If you’re looking for a flavor that screams ‘summer fun’, Pink Lemonade Pop Rocks is a sure winner.

Also Read: Best Peppermint Ice Cream Brands

9. Spicy Sriracha Ice Cream

Spicy Sriracha Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

If you’re fond of spicy food, you’ll be all over this one – Spicy Sriracha Ice Cream. Here’s a flavor that kicks the classic, sweet notes of vanilla ice cream up a notch. The initial taste is sweet and creamy, then the sriracha kicks in, bringing a wave of heat that slowly builds up. It’s a beautiful balance of sweet creaminess and fiery spice, and it’s a rollercoaster of flavors you’re sure to remember. This ice cream is not for the faint of heart, but if you’re always up for a spicy challenge, this is a dish you won’t want to pass up.

10. Goat Cheese with Red Cherries from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams

Goat Cheese with Red Cherries from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

When it comes to unusual ice cream flavors, Goat Cheese with Red Cherries from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams definitely raises some eyebrows. Cheese in ice cream is not a new concept, but goat cheese elevates the creaminess and adds a surprisingly pleasant tang to every bite. The tartness of the red cherries beautifully complements the rich, creamy goat cheese. If you have a penchant for creatively combining savory and sweet, this flavor will surely take your taste buds on a thrilling voyage.

11. Lobster Ice Cream

Lobster Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

If you thought sea critters belonged only in savory meals, you’re in for a shock with Lobster Ice Cream. This innovative flavor shifts a beloved seafood from dinner plates to dessert bowls. With chunks of fresh lobster meat swirled into a creamy ice cream base, this dish offers an unusual blend of sweet and saline. Unconventional? Yes. Delicious? Absolutely. If you thought seafood could never be a dessert, Lobster Ice Cream is here to prove you wrong.

12. Glowing Jellyfish Protein-infused Vanilla Ice Cream

Glowing Jellyfish Protein-infused Vanilla Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Time to dim the lights and cherish the perplexing allure of Glowing Jellyfish Protein-infused Vanilla Ice Cream. This ice cream not only titillates your taste buds but also delights your visual senses with its radiant blue glow. The infusion of specific proteins derived from jellyfish into a basic vanilla base offers no extraordinary taste. However, it’s the glow that steals the show. Indulging in this luminescent dessert looks nothing short of diving into the alluring depths of an enchanted ocean.

13. Extra Virgin Olive Oil from OddFellows Ice Cream

Extra Virgin Olive Oil from OddFellows Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Extra Virgin Olive Oil from OddFellows Ice Cream seamlessly bridges the gap between the savory world and the dessert realm. Combining a rich, fragrant extra virgin olive oil with a smooth and creamy ice cream base, this flavor creates a taste sensation that is both bizarre and exceptional. The olive oil gives the ice cream a delightfully smooth texture and a subtle, fruity taste, for an extravagantly luxurious experience packed in a scoop.

14. Cheetos Flamin’ Hot Ice Cream

Cheetos Flamin’ Hot Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Cheetos Flamin’ Hot Ice cream is one of those weird ice cream flavors that takes your afternoon snack to a whole new level. Combining the heat of Flamin’ Hot Cheetos and the creamy sweetness of ice cream brings together the best of both worlds – hot and cold, sweet and spicy, snack and dessert. It’s just the sort of odd mix that could become legendary in snack food history.

15. Sweet Avocado Cayenne from Rococo Creamery

Sweet Avocado Cayenne from Rococo Creamery - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Sweet Avocado Cayenne from Rococo Creamery will take you on a gastronomic adventure. The buttery goodness of avocado laced with the heat from cayenne creates a tantalizing ice cream flavor. Furthermore, the subtle sweetness balances beautifully with the hot and creamy combination. This ice cream is sure to entice those looking to try a unique twist on a sweet treat.

16. Oyster Ice Cream

Oyster Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Diving into the exceptional yet enticing world of seafood-ice cream combination, enter Oyster Ice Cream. It’s a daring flavor unique for its inclusion of marine delicacies. This semi-sweet treat is creamy, briny, and carries a hint of the sea. Truly, it’s the closest one could get to enjoying the ocean on a sundae. It might sound wildly paradoxical, yet this exciting fusion nicely brings together the icy dessert and the ocean’s freshness.

17. Vanilla with Sweet Sriracha Sauce from Mason’s Creamery

Vanilla with Sweet Sriracha Sauce from Mason’s Creamery - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Aside from the usual caramel or chocolate drizzles, we now have the Vanilla with Sweet Sriracha Sauce from Mason’s Creamery. This blend effectively plays with your palate, bringing the heat into the cold creamy vanilla. The Sriracha sauce draped over the ice cream encapsulates an exciting clash of sweet, creamy, and spicy notes. It’s a bold choice not meant for the faint-hearted, but those who dare to indulge are gulp for an intense flavor ride.

18. Pickle Ice Cream

Pickle Ice Cream - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Pickle Ice Cream seems to be an unexpected twist to the classic ice cream flavors, yet somehow it works. The sourness of pickles and the sugary sweetness of ice cream spin together an unexpected blend that’s strangely satisfying. This fascinating merger is enchanting in its own unique way, providing a sensory journey that swings between tangy, sweet, and slightly salty. It’s quirky, it’s playful, and stumbling upon this flavor might just tickle your fancy.

19. Gold Nugget from Coppa

Gold Nugget from Coppa - Weird Ice Cream Flavor of 2024

Presenting an opulent dessert experience, let’s talk about the Gold Nugget from Coppa. This isn’t your average scoop of ice cream. This extravagant dessert made with imported Italian gold leaf and French Perigord truffle is every bit as luxurious as it sounds. The truffle lends a one-of-a-kind flavor that’s indulgent and sophisticated, while the gold leaves create an irresistible sparkly aesthetic. For those looking for a scoop of luxury, this is an ice cream flavor that you have to try.

Why Trying Weird Ice Cream Flavors Can Be a Fun Experience?

As for most of us, our first ice cream encounters were likely the classic flavors – vanilla, chocolate, strawberry. But now, imagine slurping down a scoop of sweet, creamy cicada or digging into a vibrant scoop of lobster. Weird? Absolutely. Fun? Certainly. Here’s why trying these unorthodox dessert ‘delights’ could be a joyride.

Excites Your Taste Buds

Diving into weird ice cream flavors is like embarking on a thrilling journey for your taste buds. Each bite could be a surprising blend of sweet, salty, tangy, or even spicy. Take the ‘Sweet Avocado Cayenne’ from Rococo Creamery for example, it’s a captivating roller coaster for the palate.

Unconventional can be Delicious

Often, novel flavors taste more complex than traditional ones, providing an entirely new dessert experience. The ‘Pie as in Cow,‘ aka ‘Horse Flesh’ ice cream from Japan’s Vanilla Food Company, manages to blend sweet and savory in each lick, gourmands swear by it!

Conversation Starter

And let’s not ignore the perfect conversation starter it turns out to be. Sharing your adventurous culinary exploits with others is simply fun. Imagine the reactions when you reveal that you tried ‘Foie Gras’ ice cream!

Food Adventure

Explore the wildest ends of the flavor spectrum and feel like an intrepid food adventurer. As they say ‘Variety is the spice of life!’ and these outlandish flavors sure add a new level of zesty entertainment into your otherwise plain scoop.

So, why not take the plunge and add some thrill to your dessert experience? It’s time to break free from the norm and redefine fun with these weird ice cream flavors.

Why Some Exotic Flavors Become a Hit While Others Don’t?

Why Some Exotic Flavors Become a Hit While Others Don't?

Weird ice cream flavors often hinge on sea-saw of success and failure, but ever wondered what makes some hit the jackpot while others slump in disappointment?

Suitability to the Format

Firstly, the success of a variant depends heavily on its suitability to the ‘ice cream’ format. Rich and cream-based flavors tend to work well with the medium. ‘Goat Cheese with Red Cherries‘ from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams, for instance, is a hit because of its creamy consistency and the tart cherry contrast.

Balance in Flavor

Maintaining a balance in flavor, is also crucial. For instance, the ‘Extra Virgin Olive Oil‘ ice cream from OddFellows curates a delightful balance with its sweetness complementing the fruitiness of the olive oil.

Novelty Vs Usability

Often the shock factor can earn brownie points. The amazing ‘Glowing jellyfish protein-infused Vanilla‘ ice cream certainly grabs attention with its glow-in-the-dark gimmick. But longevity is a different ball game altogether. A flavor that seems too strange or challenging might attract attention initially but can fail to accumulate a regular consumer base. Hence, the novelty factor has to balance out with usability for the long run.

Cultural and Regional Preferences

Regional and cultural preferences also play a significant role. A flavor that’s popular in Japan, like the ‘Horse Flesh‘ ice cream might not resonate well with Western consumers.

So, while it is fascinating to churn-out crazy ice cream flavors, achieving the right equilibrium of taste, texture, and acceptability is vital for a flavor to be a hit. Thus, not all exotic ice cream flavors manage to endure the test of taste buds and consumers alike. The key rests in providing a unique, yet satisfying eating experience that customers would want to revisit.

Also Read: Best Jeni’s Ice Cream Flavors

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some of the weirdest ice cream flavors in the world?

Some of the weirdest ice cream flavors you can find include Thanksgiving Dinner, Pizza, Cicada, Horse Flesh, Strawberry Balsamic, Chili Peppermint, Foie Gras, and even Lobster and Oyster.

Is weird ice cream safe to eat?

Absolutely! As strange as these flavors may sound, they are produced with edible ingredients and pass necessary food safety standards.

Where can I find weird ice cream flavors?

Many of these flavors are unique to specific ice cream shops and regions. For instance, Horse Flesh ice cream is a rarity found only in Japan.

Does weird ice cream have a big following?

While these eccentric flavors represent a niche market, there’s a growing trend toward adventurous eating, and these unique ice creams are becoming increasingly popular.

Will there be more weird ice cream flavors in the future?

The ice cream world thrives on innovation, you never know what strange yet tantalizing flavor might churn up next!

Are all weird ice cream flavors savory?

Interestingly no, there is a mix. From strawberry balsamic to goat cheese with red cherries, these flavors span the gamut from savory to sweet.

Can I make my own weird ice cream flavors at home?

With the right ingredients and a good ice cream maker, the sky’s the limit! You can experiment with your own crazy concoctions.

Do these weird flavors actually taste good?

Taste is subjective and varies from person to person. Some people absolutely enjoy the daring blend of unfamiliar tastes, while others prefer the traditional flavors.

Are any of these weird ice cream flavors vegan?

It would depend on the specific flavor and ingredients used. Many ice cream shops offer vegan versions of their unique flavors.

Can I order these weird ice cream flavors online?

Depending on the ice cream parlor and their shipping policies, you may be able to order these crazy flavors right to your doorstep.


In a world that never ceases to surprise us, it’s only fitting that we’d find such a thrillingly bizarre array of ice cream flavors. While some of these flavors may initially provoke a shudder of disbelief, they underscore the beauty of culinary innovation and our inherent desire to experiment and push boundaries. Unusual? Absolutely! Unappetizing? Not quite. Most of these weird ice cream flavors have found their own niche following, proving that when it comes to ice cream, there’s something enduringly delightful about discovering new tastes and textures that venture far beyond the ordinary scoop.

Whether you are an adventurous foodie or a comfort food connoisseur, these offbeat ice cream flavors open a Pandora’s box of tantalizing thrills and spills. Who knows? You might just find your new favorite among these curious concoctions. Until then, keep that spoon ready and your mind open, because in the world of ice cream, anything is tantalizingly possible!

Food Lover and Storyteller 🍽️✨ With a fork in one hand and a pen in the other, Shivani brings her culinary adventures to life through evocative words and tantalizing tastes. Her love for food knows no bounds, and she's on a mission to share the magic of flavors with fellow enthusiasts.
Related Articles from the same category:
This is a blog for Travellers & Travel Lovers
Copyright 2023 - All Rights Reserved.