Sixstoreys Logo

12 Best Carl’s Jr. Sauces Ranked 2024 [Taste the Top Picks]

By: Shivani Choudhary
Updated On: April 30, 2024

As a self-proclaimed fast food enthusiast, I can’t help but share my fascination with the world of rich and delectable sauces. There’s just something irresistible about the way a simple condiment can elevate a meal from ordinary to extraordinary. And Carl’s Jr, a brand with a reputation for mouthwatering burgers and top-notch quality, holds a special place in my heart, not only for their tasty main dishes but also for the impressive array of sauces they offer to tantalize their customers’ taste buds.

Over the years, I’ve come to strongly believe that an outstanding sauce can make all the difference in a meal, and Carl’s Jr has proven time and time again that they are masters of the sauce game. In this article, I invite you to embark on a journey of flavorful discovery as we explore the sensational realm of best Carl’s Jr sauces.

We’ll delve into the classics that have become staples in the fast-food world, dabble in the spicy sensations that ignite the palate, and uncover the elusive secret menu, leaving no stone unturned in our quest for saucy knowledge.

Whether you’re a seasoned Carl’s Jr fan or simply a curious foodie, I’m confident that this flavorful guide will bring newfound appreciation and understanding to the wonderful world of sauces. So grab a fork, a plate, and your sense of culinary adventure, as we dive into the fabulous variety that lies within the universe of Carl’s Jr dipping sauces.

Also Read: What Time Does Carl’s Jr Start Serving Lunch?

12 Best Carl’s Jr. Sauces Ranked As of 2024

Classics Never Go Out of Style - Carl's Jr Iconic Sauces (2023)

As the old adage goes, “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” In the world of fast food, there are certain sauces that have stood the test of time, cementing their place as iconic accompaniments to our favorite burger joints. Carl’s Jr is no exception; their menu boasts a range of tried and true classics, which have won the hearts and taste buds of customers for decades.

Let’s take a closer look at the iconic Carl’s Jr sauces that have captured our hearts and keep us coming back for more.

1. Santa Fe Sauce: A blend of creamy ranch with a hint of spice

Santa Fe Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

The Santa Fe sauce is the epitome of flavor fusion, blending the best of two worlds – creamy ranch and zesty spices. With its rich texture and smooth finish, this sauce is perfect for drizzling over Carl’s Jr’s signature Western Bacon Cheeseburger or dipping their crisp Crisscut fries.

A bite of Santa Fe sauce transports your taste buds on a flavorful adventure to the rugged, sun-kissed Southwest. One could argue that it’s the embodiment of culinary treasure, just waiting to be discovered by eager palates everywhere.

2. BBQ Sauce: A Rich Smoky Flavor

BBQ Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

BBQ sauce is arguably one of the most beloved and versatile sauces in fast-food history, balancing a combination of smokiness, sweetness, and tanginess. At Carl’s Jr, their BBQ sauce is crafted with utmost attention to detail, delivering a delectable taste that complements a wide array of menu items.

From heightening the flavors of their juicy charbroiled burgers to adding a savory coating to their tender chicken strips, the BBQ sauce never fails to impress. It’s timeless appeal and culinary versatility make it an indispensable part of the Carl’s Jr sauce lineup.

3. Buttermilk Ranch: Creamy, and Cool

Buttermilk Ranch - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

There’s something undeniably comforting about the cool, creamy taste of buttermilk ranch dressing. This classic sauce is a favorite among fast food enthusiasts, and Carl’s Jr’s version hits all the right notes. Smooth, flavorful, and with just the right amount of tang, this sauce is the ultimate dipping companion for a wide range of dishes, from fried zucchini to their Famous Star with Cheese.

Its cool and refreshing taste is also an excellent choice for balancing spicy menu items, like the Jalapeño Poppers or the Fiery Chicken Sandwich. A dollop of buttermilk ranch adds a touch of indulgence and richness to any meal and serves as a delicious reminder of why these classic sauces never go out of style.

4. Honey Mustard: Combination of Sweetness and Tang

Honey Mustard - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Honey mustard is a sauce that truly has a personality all its own — bringing together the sweet and mellow flavors of honey with the sharp, tangy zing of mustard. This sauce is perfect for dipping crispy chicken tenders or adding an extra layer of flavor to a grilled chicken sandwich.

Let’s not forget how this delightful sauce also works magic when paired with Carl’s Jr’s hand-breaded Chicken Tenders, enhancing their already scrumptious flavor. A dollop of honey mustard sauce effortlessly elevates a meal, transforming it into a symphony of sweet, tangy notes, making it one of Carl’s Jr’s undeniable classics.

5. Buffalo Sauce: Seek Heat in The Meal [Best Carl’s Jr Hot Sauce]

Buffalo Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

As a fiery fan favorite, the Buffalo sauce at Carl’s Jr was created for those who crave a zingy sensation with every bite. This luscious red sauce balances the bold heat of cayenne pepper with a smooth touch of tanginess from vinegar, creating an unforgettable flavor profile.

The result? An exquisite thrill to your taste buds that pairs sublimely with chicken wings or even as an adventurous addition to your classic burger. If you haven’t yet tried dipping your salty, crispy fries into this spicy and tangy treasure, now is the time – you definitely won’t be disappointed.

6. Hot Sauce: A Fiery Addition

Hot Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

For those who aren’t satisfied by any dish unless it boasts some serious heat, Carl’s Jr has answered the call in the form of their aptly-named Hot Sauce. Serving up a generous dose of pure fire from crushed hot peppers along with undertones bursting with vibrant flavors like onion and garlic, this saucy gem is bound to leave you breathing fire (in a good way).

Its powerful zesty characteristics make it ideal for punching up your favorite burger – whether beef or spicy chicken – giving them an extra kick that will undoubtedly leave behind sultry memories akin to its sizzling warmth.

7. Green Sauce: Zesty and Tangy Concoction

Green Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Feeling experimental? Itching for something truly unique? Look no further than Carl’s Jr’s signature Green Sauce. This distinctive masterpiece starts off on slightly milder footing compared to its spicy siblings but doesn’t shy away from making its presence known on any dish it graces.

Featuring bright notes of fresh cilantro merged seamlessly amongst rich jalapeño flavorings (nothing short of genius), this magical green elixir truly shines when drizzled over nachos or embraced wholeheartedly alongside grilled cheddar bites buffalo wings standing bathed in glorious brightness.

If your fast-food feast is missing a touch of verdant freshness that can only come from tangy Green Sauce coaxing heat to tippy-top heights, prepare to be delighted by this unforgettable Carl’s Jr specialty.

Also Read: Burger King Sauces

8. Ketchup: The Timeless Tomato Treasure

Ketchup - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Ketchup is often dismissed as “just” a kid-friendly sauce, but the truth is told, it has an enduring appeal that transcends age and culture boundaries. This tomato-based condiment is undeniably versatile – offering just enough sweetness to balance out savory dishes, while its mild hint of vinegar adds an understated tanginess that enhances flavor profiles across various menu items.

At Carl’s Jr., ketchup shines as a go-to companion for crispy fries or onion rings adding depth to their flavors while also being an excellent addition to their mouthwatering hamburgers.

9. Mayonnaise: The Subtle Touch of Creamy Decadence

Mayonnaise - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

As unassuming as it might appear in its plain white form, mayonnaise holds the power to elevate any dish with its rich and velvety texture. Comprised primarily of oil and egg yolk – occasionally flavored with additional seasoning – mayonnaise brings forward a sense of culinary opulence without overpowering other flavors on your plate.

In Carl’s Jr.’s delectable menu offerings, this creamy goodness complements not only sandwiches such as The Big Hamburger or Charbroiled Chicken Club Sandwich but also works marvelously even with fried delights such as the Crisscut Fries. Often underestimated, this condiment adds a cohesive deliciousness to each bite ensuring a satisfactory dining experience.

10. Sweet and Bold BBQ Sauce

Sweet and Bold BBQ Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Introducing the Sweet and Bold BBQ Sauce – an ambrosial creation that strikes a harmonious balance between sweetness and boldness without overpowering your taste buds. This sauce is crafted with utmost care using a top-secret blend of premium ingredients, which creates a luscious texture that clings beautifully to every bite, drenching it in mouthwatering goodness.

The next time you visit Carl’s Jr, don’t forget to pair this sweet-savory treat with chicken tenders or any protein-packed dish of your choice.

11. Carl’s Jr Special Sauce

Special Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Among Carl’s Jr hidden gems lies their tantalizing Special Sauce – an enigmatic concoction shrouded in mystery yet brimming with flavor. While its exact components remain undisclosed, rumor has it that this divine spread consists of select spices blended seamlessly with mayo for a smooth finish that melts over your tongue like silk.

Perfect as an accompaniment for various menu items, this unassuming sauce packs quite the punch by offering deliciousness wrapped in secrecy.

12. Creamy Tartar Sauce

Creamy Tartar Sauce - best Carl's Jr Sauces of 2023

Fish lovers rejoice! The delectable Creamy Tartar sauce from Carl’s Jr is here to elevate your fish sandwich experience into something truly exceptional! Crafted from an exquisite blend of finely chopped pickles, onions, capers, and herbs married alongside creamy mayonnaise – this scrumptious variety lends itself well when served with a generous helping of crispy beer-battered fish fillets.

Each bite is greeted with the perfect combination of tangy zest and creamy delight, solidifying this sauce as an absolute must-try when indulging in your next Fish Sandwich order at Carl’s Jr.

Discovering New Combos – Tips for Mixing and Matching Carl’s Jr Sauces

One of the greatest joys I’ve found in exploring the world of fast food sauces, like those at Carl’s Jr, is the limitless potential for creating exciting new flavor combinations.

By mixing and matching these tasty condiments, you can develop unique mouthwatering experiences that perfectly cater to your personal preferences and make each meal a brand-new adventure. Before experimenting with sauce combos yourself, here are a few tips to spark your creativity:

  • Start with complementary flavors: If you’re unsure about how two particular sauces might work together, think about their dominant flavors and whether they tend to pair well in other dishes or cuisines. A classic example from Carl’s Jr would be blending Honey Mustard (sweet) with BBQ Sauce (smoky); combined; these two create a perfect balance between sweet complexity and savory depth.
  • Know when opposites attract: While complementing flavors works wonders in many cases, don’t hesitate to explore seemingly opposite flavors that might actually blend harmoniously – so long as they won’t overpower each other too much. For instance, try combining the creamy Buttermilk Ranch with daring Buffalo Sauce for an irresistible fusion of cool creaminess meeting zesty heat.
  • Enhance classics by adding an unexpected twist: Take your favorite Carl’s Jr sauce and give it a flavor upgrade by simply adding another sauce into the mix or using it as a “topper.” You could take something like Honey Mustard Sauce up a notch by incorporating Hot Sauce for an added kick.
  • Ask for extra sauces on the side: Don’t restrict yourself only to what’s already on your burger or sandwich! Feel free to ask if any additional sauces can be provided separately when placing your order so you can indulge in creative experimentation without worrying about ruining your meal should any unwanted combinations occur.
  • Share with friends: It’s always more fun when you have company during your culinary experiments! Share your favorite mixes or newly discovered combinations with friends, and learn from their own discoveries. You never know who might stumble upon an absolute winner.
  • Trust in the power of trial and error: Mixing and matching sauces at Carl’s Jr is all about stepping out of your comfort zone to find new favorites. Remember, not all combos will be successful, but persistent exploration will reveal blends that might just become your next must-have order!

Armed with these tips as you combine and sample the myriad of Carl’s Jr sauces at your disposal, you’ll be well on your way to unearthing a whole universe of unforgettable flavors that are truly customizable for endless enjoyment.

Carl’s Jr Sauces Recipes to Try at Home (2024) – Unleashing your Inner Chef

Carl’s Jr Sauce Recipes to Try at Home (2023) - Unleashing your Inner Chef

As a devoted fan of Carl’s Jr sauces, I sometimes crave those flavors even when I’m not planning to visit their restaurant. Upon realizing that some fellow sauce aficionados must share this sentiment, I decided to embark on a culinary adventure in recreating some of my beloved Carl’s Jr sauces at home.

The good news? It’s easier than you might think! Whether you want to enjoy them with your homemade burgers or simply have an irresistible dipping sauce for your fries and chicken tenders, these simple recipes will help you bring the essence of Carl’s Jr right into your kitchen.

1. Homemade Buttermilk Ranch

Homemade Buttermilk Ranch - Carl's Jr Sauces Recipe


  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/2 cup buttermilk
  • 1/2 teaspoon dried chives
  • 1/2 teaspoon dried parsley
  • 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
  • Salt and pepper, to taste


Combine all ingredients in a bowl, whisking until smooth. Refrigerate for at least one hour before serving for flavors to blend together.

2. Honey Mustard Sauce from Scratch

Honey Mustard Sauce from Scratch - Carl's Jr Sauces Recipe


  • 1/2 cup mayonnaise
  • 3 tablespoons honey
  • 3 tablespoons Dijon mustard
  • Pinch of paprika


In a small bowl, mix all the ingredients together until well combined. Cover and refrigerate until ready to serve.

3. Smoky Homemade BBQ Sauce

Smoky Homemade BBQ Sauce - Carl's Jr Sauces Recipe


  • 1 cup ketchup
  • ¼ cup apple cider vinegar
    -¼ cup brown sugar
    –packed tightly,
    – tightly packed brown sugar,
    – teaspoons Worcestershire sauce,
    – tablespoon paprika,
    – less than cayenne pepper (to taste),
    A pinch of salt and freshly ground black pepper are added to the spices before mixing the mustard.


Combine all ingredients in a saucepan over medium heat. Simmer for about 20 minutes, stirring occasionally, until flavors meld together. Allow it to cool before transferring to a jar or serving dish.

4. Spicing Up Your Kitchen – Buffalo Sauce

Buffalo Sauce - Carl's Jr Sauces Recipe


  • 1/2 cup hot sauce (e.g., Frank’s RedHot)
  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter
  • A pinch of garlic powder
  • A dash of Worcestershire sauce


Melt the butter in a small saucepan over low heat. Stir in hot sauce, garlic powder, and Worcestershire sauce until well combined. Cook for about 5 minutes on low heat before removing it from the stove and allowing it to cool slightly before use.

Hints for Perfect Sauce Preparation

  1. Taste as you go – Adjust seasoning levels to match your personal preferences.
  2. Get creative – Use these recipes as a starting point; feel free to experiment with other herbs, spices, or even hot sauces.
  3. Prepare ahead of time – Make sure you have all ingredients on hand and allow enough time for flavors to blend together properly by refrigerating homemade sauces at least an hour prior to serving.
  4. Store safely – Transfer homemade sauces into airtight containers and store them in the refrigerator when not using them immediately.

Also Read: Best Trader Joe’s Pasta Sauces

Searching for the Perfect Sauce: My Personal Journey

Searching for the Perfect Sauce: My Personal Journey

As a die-hard fast-food enthusiast, I have always been on a never-ending quest to find that perfect sauce that makes my taste buds sing in harmony. It’s safe to say that through trial and error, memorable experiences, and endless flavorful meals, Carl’s Jr has become one of my favorite destinations when it comes to remarkable sauce combinations.

My journey began during my college days when late-night hunger pangs led me and my friends on an exciting gastronomical adventure. Soon enough, we had developed our own Saturday night ritual – trying out different menu items at Carl’s Jr while mixing and matching various sauces. We even gave ourselves the title “Sauce Scientists,” as each week we experimented with different pairings to discover which combination worked best with our indulgent treats.

Out of all the sauces offered at Carl’s Jr., Honey Mustard holds a dear place in my heart. One bite dipped into this perfectly balanced concoction of sweetness and tanginess transports me back to those carefree college times filled with laughter and camaraderie shared amongst friends. Another standout from their range is their Special Sauce – mysterious in its flavor profile but undoubtedly delectable every single time.

As I continued exploring new avenues within the realm of sauces at Carl’s Jr., I became increasingly adventurous in my choices. Considering both taste preferences and texture appearances (for example, whether the burger calls for a smooth or chunky sauce), I soon identified hit pairings such as Santa Fe Sauce over Fried Zucchini slices or Barbecue Sauce slathered generously over Crisscut Fries.

While sharing these flavorful discoveries with friends or family members who also possessed an appreciation for saucy goodness brought about unforgettable moments around the dinner table (or sometimes, inside the car), it was eventually time to take matters into my own hands – literally! Upon recreating several iconic Carl’s Jr sauces at home using online recipes, I discovered the unique satisfaction that comes from enhancing a simple meal with a homemade touch.

Although my pursuit of the perfect sauce may never truly end, Carl’s Jr has undeniably played an influential role in shaping my appreciation for all things saucy. As I continue to embark on this flavorful escapade in search of unexplored combinations and new depths of deliciousness, I hope that sharing these experiences encourages others to do the same – discovering, through a myriad of delectable sauces, their own versions of culinary perfection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most popular sauces at Carl’s Jr?

Some of the most popular choices include Santa Fe Sauce, Honey Mustard, BBQ Sauce, and Buttermilk Ranch.

Are there any spicy sauce options available at Carl’s Jr?

Yes! If you’re looking for some heat, you can try their Buffalo Sauce or Hot Sauce.

Can I mix and match Carl’s Jr sauces when I order?

Absolutely! Feel free to get creative by combining different sauces or layering multiple sauces on your burger or sandwich.

Can I purchase bottles of my favorite Carl’s Jr dipping sauces to take home?

Some locations may offer bottled versions of their signature sauces for sale; however, it varies between restaurants. Alternatively, you can search online for recipes to recreate the flavors at home.

Do all the Carl’s Jr locations carry the same selection of available sauces?

While most locations should carry a majority of these mentioned in this article., regional variances may exist so it is advisable to check with your local store for specific availability.

Are there vegan or gluten-free sauce options available at Carl’s Jr?

Some locations may provide allergen-friendly options such as gluten-free BBQ Sauce or vegan mayo, however,__it varies between locations. Always ask the restaurant staff about those specific preferences when placing your order.


As we come to the end of our flavorful journey, it’s evident that Carl’s Jr is truly a haven for sauce enthusiasts, offering an extraordinary variety that creates memorable and satisfying dining experiences. Stepping out of your comfort zone, and trying new flavors or daring combinations at Carl’s Jr will not only make each visit uniquely exciting but also give you the chance to find your own signature sauce pairing.

So next time you sink your teeth into one of their scrumptious burgers or snack on a box of crispy chicken tenders, don’t be shy to experiment with their delicious sauces – after all, life is too short for bland food.

Moreover, I hope this guide has inspired you to appreciate the transformative power and culinary artistry hidden in every bottle or dipping cup filled with these scrumptious condiments. With Carl’s Jr as our prime example, may we all embrace diving into the world of sauces with sheer curiosity and enthusiasm.

Who knows? You might just find yourself discovering new favorites along the way or feel empowered to concoct some amazing homemade creations based on what you’ve learned here today. So go forth and let your taste buds do some exploring – because sometimes we need an extraordinary sauce to bring out the real magic in a meal!

Food Lover and Storyteller 🍽️✨ With a fork in one hand and a pen in the other, Shivani brings her culinary adventures to life through evocative words and tantalizing tastes. Her love for food knows no bounds, and she's on a mission to share the magic of flavors with fellow enthusiasts.
Related Articles from the same category:
This is a blog for Travellers & Travel Lovers
Copyright 2023 - All Rights Reserved.