Sixstoreys Logo

19 Best Store-Bought Tartar Sauce Brands To Buy in 2024

By: Shivani Choudhary
Updated On: August 30, 2023

Finding the perfect companion for your favorite seafood dishes can be a culinary adventure, and that’s where discovering the best store-bought tartar sauce brands comes into play. Tartar sauce, a delectable blend of mayonnaise, capers, pickles, and various herbs and spices, has long been a beloved condiment for seafood lovers everywhere. As the variety of brands expands, it becomes crucial to choose the right one that complements and elevates your dishes.

In this blog post, I’ll be diving into the world of tartar sauce, providing you with insights on some of the top contenders and ultimately, helping you find the best tartar sauce brand to suit your preferences and enhance your culinary experience. So set your sails and get ready for a journey of flavors!

Also Read: Best Store-Bought Enchilada Sauces

Article Includes

The Top 19 Contenders For Store-Bought Tartar Sauce Brands in 2024

The Top Contenders For Tartar Sauce Brands in 2023

As we embark on this voyage to uncover the best tartar sauce brand, let’s first take a look at the top contenders that have captured the hearts and taste buds of many seafood lovers. These brands have consistently ranked high in terms of flavor, texture, and overall quality. Here, we’ll dive into what makes each of these top-notch brands a fan favorite.

1. McCormick Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce Original

McCormick Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce Original - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

McCormick has long been a staple in kitchens worldwide and their Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce Original is no exception. With a commitment to using only the highest-quality ingredients, this tartar sauce ticks all the boxes for what you would expect from a top contender. The fresh and tangy flavors are carefully mixed to ensure they remain balanced and practically beg to be paired with your favorite seafood.

The velvety texture of this tartar sauce adds a layer of indulgence to each bite, and its versatility makes it a must-have condiment in your pantry. Whether served with fish sticks, shrimp, or a crispy fish fillet, McCormick’s Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce is sure to leave you wanting more.

2. Inglehoffer Seafood Tartar Sauce

Inglehoffer Seafood Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Coming up next is the Inglehoffer Seafood Tartar Sauce, a zesty and exciting option for those who love a bit of extra kick in their sauce. Made with premium ingredients, this tartar sauce has a unique blend of flavors that sets it apart from its competitors.

Inglehoffer ensures that convenience is never compromised – their 8.25-ounce squeeze bottle makes it easy to transfer the perfect amount of tartar sauce to your plate, and you’ll never have to worry about making a mess.

This sauce has a loyal following for good reason – the tangy, pickle-forward taste is unbeatable, and it pairs wonderfully with a wide variety of dishes. Give Inglehoffer Seafood Tartar Sauce a try, and I guarantee it will make its way into your regular meal rotation!

3. Primal Kitchen Entertaining Tartar Sauce

Primal Kitchen Entertaining Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Let’s continue our quest for the best tartar sauce brand with Primal Kitchen Entertaining Tartar Sauce. This delicious sauce is an excellent choice for those who prefer healthier, all-natural options. The uncompromising commitment to quality has placed Primal Kitchen among the favorites of many health-conscious consumers.

This scrumptious sauce is not only packed with flavor but is also paleo-friendly! Primal Kitchen uses only the finest ingredients, creating a creamy tartar sauce that will make your taste buds sing. The perfectly balanced flavors make it an ideal match for a wide range of seafood dishes, ensuring your meals are nothing short of spectacular.

4. Louisiana Home Style Tartar Sauce

Louisiana Home Style Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

One of the first options in Louisiana Tartar Style Sauces is the Louisiana Home Style Tartar Sauce. This delectable sauce comes in a 10.5 oz jar, offering ample opportunity for you to savor its flavor. A blend of tangy mayonnaise, zesty lemon, and just the right hint of seasoning creates a delightfully balanced taste that transports your senses straight to the heart of the Bayou.

The Louisiana Home Style Tartar Sauce is perfect for pairing with your favorite fish dishes, whether fried, grilled, or baked. Why not try it with a batch of spicy fried catfish or freshly steamed shrimp? This versatile sauce adds a layer of Southern flair to every seafood dish, making it a must-try for any tartar sauce lover.

5. Louisiana Fish Fry, Tartar Sauce

Louisiana Fish Fry Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

The second offering in our Louisiana Tartar Style Sauces lineup is the Louisiana Fish Fry, Tartar Sauce. This sauce comes in a 10.5 oz jar and delivers a unique blend of flavors that perfectly accentuates your fish meals. The combination of tangy mayonnaise, vibrant pickles, and spices melds together to create a harmonious symphony of flavors that leaves you craving more.

If you want to truly appreciate the depth and palate of the Louisiana Fish Fry, Tartar Sauce, pair it with a mouthwatering, freshly-fried flounder, or a plate of beer-battered shrimp. The zesty taste and pleasant heat of this sauce will take your dish from ordinary to extraordinary, as you discover a whole new world of culinary possibilities.

In conclusion, if you’re in search of adventurous flavors that capture the essence of the Deep South, Louisiana Tartar Style Sauces should be a top contender on your radar. Bring these sauces to your table and let your taste buds embark on an unforgettable journey.

6. Frisch’s Sauce Tartar Original

Frisch's Sauce Tartar Original - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Frisch’s Sauce Tartar Original is a popular tartar sauce boasting a perfect balance of smoothness and tanginess. This exquisite condiment features a blend of mayo, sweet relish, and spices, creating a one-of-a-kind flavor experience.


  • Smooth and creamy texture
  • Distinctive taste that seafood aficionados will love
  • Enhances many dishes, from classic fish and chips to crab cakes

7. Frisch’s Big Boy Original Tartar Sauce

Frisch's Big Boy Original Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Frisch’s Big Boy Original Tartar Sauce is sold in a convenient double pack of 9 oz jars, ensuring you always have a great stock of this beloved condiment. Similar to the Sauce Tartar Original, this variant too offers a well-balanced flavor profile. The unique combination of ingredients in this sauce guarantees to take your seafood dishes to a whole new level.


  • Exceptional taste and quality
  • Pairs well with all types of seafood dishes
  • Versatile condiment for sandwiches and other meals
  • Convenient double pack for added value

Also Read: Best Sauces For Lobster Ravioli

8. Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce

Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce stands unrivaled with its appealing taste, as well as its all-natural and health-conscious ingredients. Crafted with a unique blend of avocado oil, capers, parsley, and Dijon mustard, this tartar sauce expertly balances flavors, providing a burst of freshness with every bite.

Being vegan, keto, and paleo-friendly, this tartar sauce caters to a diverse range of diets, ensuring that no one has to miss out on the delight of seafood. You can relish this guilt-free accompaniment to your dishes as it contains no added sugars or artificial preservatives.

9. Primal Kitchen Chipotle Tartar Sauce

Primal Kitchen Chipotle Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

For those who crave an added kick in their tartar sauce, look no further than Primal Kitchen Chipotle Tartar Sauce. Incorporating the smoky zest of chipotle sauce into the classic tartar base, this innovative mixture beautifully complements any seafood dish.

The non-traditional twist comes together with a rich and creamy texture. It offers a burst of heat for daring palates, making it the perfect choice for those seeking more than just a mild and tangy taste. In addition, this tartar sauce remains true to Primal Kitchen’s commitment to wholesome ingredients, boasting a no added sugar and preservative-free formula.

10. Ken’s Foods 1 Gallon Tartar Sauce

Ken's Foods 1 Gallon Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Ken’s Foods has been known for its culinary prowess for more than 60 years and their 1 Gallon Tartar Sauce is no exception. This restaurant-style sauce is perfect for those who enjoy a lot of tartar sauce or catering events. The bold and tangy flavor of this sauce complements various seafood dishes, from classic fish and chips to grilled shrimp.

The generous 1-gallon package size offers excellent value for money, especially for restaurants, caterers, or anyone looking for a bulk option. Moreover, the quality of this tartar sauce ensures that your dishes will be consistently delicious every time you use it.

11. Kraft Tartar Sauce

Kraft Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Kraft is a name synonymous with high-quality condiments, and their Tartar Sauce continues that legacy. This classic tartar sauce is both smooth and tangy, making it a reliable choice for all your seafood cravings.

Conveniently packaged in a 12 fl oz squeeze bottle, this tartar sauce is well-suited for family gatherings or home cooking and allows for easy portion control. The taste of Kraft Tartar Sauce is sure to remind you of your favorite nostalgic seafood dishes.

12. Kraft Natural Lemon Flavor & Herb Tartar Sauce

Kraft Natural Lemon Flavor & Herb Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

If you appreciate a unique twist on a classic, look no further than Kraft Natural Lemon Flavor & Herb Tartar Sauce. The infusion of natural lemon flavor and herbs adds a delightful citrusy zest to this tartar sauce, making it ideal for fish and seafood dishes.

This tartar sauce also comes in a convenient squeezy bottle, making it easy to drizzle the perfect amount onto your plate. The creative combination of flavors in Kraft Natural Lemon Flavor & Herb Tartar Sauce is perfect for those seeking a refreshing and zesty tartar sauce option for their meals.

13. Captain Toady’s Tartar Sauce Dill

Captain Toady's Tartar Sauce Dill - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Captain Toady’s Tartar Sauce Dill is a deliciously inventive take on the traditional tartar sauce recipe. This game-changing sauce incorporates the lively herb, dill, which gives it a refreshing, slightly tangy taste. Complemented by a harmonious blend of classic ingredients like mayonnaise, diced pickles, and an array of spices, this dill-infused creation adds a delightful depth of flavor to all your favorite seafood dishes. Ideal for pairing with battered fish, shrimp, or even crab cakes, Captain Toady’s Tartar Sauce Dill can transform any meal into an unforgettable culinary adventure.

14. Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce

Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

If you’ve ever had the opportunity to dine in one of Legal Sea Foods’ renowned restaurants, you’ll understand the hype around their House Tartar Sauce. This acclaimed sauce reflects the impeccable standards for which the restaurant is renowned, capturing the essence of its flavorful seafood dishes.

Made with premium-quality ingredients, this luxurious tartar sauce strikes the perfect balance between creamy and tangy, making it an exquisite accompaniment to all your seafood favorites. A jar of Legal Sea Foods House Tartar Sauce on your table is a testament to your connoisseurship and a surefire way to elevate your dining experience.

15. Norman Bishop Lemon and Dill Tartar Sauce

Norman Bishop Lemon and Dill Tartar Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Searching for a gourmet condiment that’s worthy of your most elegant dishes? Look no further than Norman Bishop Lemon and Dill Tartar Sauce. This sumptuous sauce skillfully infuses zesty lemon and aromatic dill into its rich, creamy base, creating a blend of flavors that burst onto your palate like a symphony.

Whether you’re enjoying it with a succulent salmon fillet or a platter of juicy shrimp, this luxuriant tartar sauce brings a touch of sophistication to your dining table. Differentiate yourself from the ordinary and indulge in the refined taste of Norman Bishop Lemon and Dill Tartar Sauce—your taste buds will thank you!

16. Bookbinder’s Sauce Tartar

Bookbinder's Sauce Tartar - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Bookbinder’s Sauce Tartar is a rich and creamy condiment that delivers a harmonious blend of flavors. It comes in a 9.5 oz jar, allowing you to indulge in its delightful taste whenever you please. This sauce’s recipe is carefully crafted, paying attention to each ingredient and its proportions, ensuring that you get the perfect balance of tang, sweetness, and spiciness in every spoonful.

Its masterful blend of flavors pairs exquisitely with a variety of seafood dishes. Exceptional with both fried and grilled fish, you’ll be reaching for this jar time and time again. A dollop of this extraordinary sauce will transport your taste buds to another level of scrumptiousness.

17. Original Colman’s Tartare Sauce

Original Colman's Tartare Sauce - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Venture into the wonderful world of the Original Colman’s Tartare Sauce, a traditional British favorite that boasts a unique flavor profile. The distinctly British taste of this tartar sauce makes it perfect for pairing with classic fish and chips, as well as a variety of other seafood dishes like crab cakes or even fried calamari.

The sharpness of the capers, combined with the kick of lemon and mustard, creates an addictive explosion of taste that truly distinguishes Colman’s from its competitors. Its tangy, zesty flavor will have you coming back for more, making it an essential addition to your condiment cupboard. Don’t miss the opportunity to bring home a taste of British tradition with this delicious sauce.

18. Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet

Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet  - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Heinz is a well-known and trusted brand that has been delighting taste buds for generations. Their Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet offers the classic and tangy flavor you crave in a convenient and portable packaging. Ideal for picnics, lunches, or outdoor gatherings, these individual packets are perfect for on-the-go and ensure no waste.

Say goodbye to the mess and fuss of traditional jars, and experience the satisfyingly rich and creamy texture of Heinz’s tartar sauce. Serve it alongside fish sticks, shrimp, or your favorite seafood dish for a foolproof flavor pairing. Trust in the quality and consistency of Heinz Tartar Sauce Single Serve Packet for a no-fuss condiment choice.

19. Duke’s Tartar Sauce

Duke's Tartar Sauce  - Best Tartar Sauce Brand

If you’re looking for a tartar sauce that promises to deliver no-fuss flavor, then Duke’s Tartar Sauce is the answer. Boasting a smooth, tangy taste, this condiment elevates any dish it accompanies. With just the right balance of zesty pickles and rich mayonnaise, you’ll find it hard to resist the temptation to dip everything in Duke’s.

This conveniently packaged 8.0 fl oz bottle minimizes mess and simplifies storage, so you can confidently take it on picnics and outdoor events. Duke’s Tartar Sauce is the perfect companion for any seafood dish – whether it’s your classic fish and chips or a scrumptious seared salmon. Indulge in the simplicity and satisfaction of a tried-and-true brand that continues to impress.

Also Read: Best Red Robin Sauces

Why Tartar Sauce is a Must-Have for Seafood Lovers?

Why Tartar Sauce is a Must-Have for Seafood Lovers?

History of Tartar Sauce

Tartar sauce’s origins can be traced back to France in the 1800s, when it was introduced as a delectable accompaniment to seafood dishes. The traditional recipe comprises mayonnaise, capers, pickles, and a medley of herbs and spices. Over time, tartar sauce has gained popularity across the globe and can now be found in various regional and international versions.

Benefits of Tartar Sauce for Enhancing Flavor Profiles

Tartar sauce is a must-have for seafood lovers due to its ability to complement and elevate the taste of fish and other seafood dishes. The perfect blend of creamy, tangy, and zesty elements found in tartar sauce adds depth to the flavor of delicate fish, providing a richer dining experience. Additionally, tartar sauce balances the natural oils in fish, especially fried preparations, and offers a delightful contrast that leaves the palate craving more.

Homemade vs. Store-Bought: The Great Tartar Sauce Debate

Homemade vs. Store-Bought: The Great Tartar Sauce Debate

Pros and Cons of Making Your Own Tartar Sauce

Homemade tartar sauce allows for total control over the ingredients, which means customization is possible to suit individual preferences and dietary needs. By making it from scratch, you can also ensure the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients. However, the downside of homemade tartar sauce is the time and effort required to source and prepare the ingredients, which can be daunting for some busy home cooks.

Time and Effort Considerations

Store-bought tartar sauce presents a convenient option for those who don’t want to invest time and energy in making their own. High-quality brands can offer delicious flavor profiles that are ready to be enjoyed straight from the jar or bottle. However, store-bought options may contain preservatives, artificial flavorings, or thickeners, which may not be suitable for individuals with specific dietary restrictions.

Ultimately, the choice between homemade and store-bought tartar sauce comes down to personal preferences, dietary needs, and how much time one is willing to dedicate to the preparation process.

5 Tips for Storing Tartar Sauce to Maintain Freshness

Tartar sauce can last a long time if properly stored, ensuring that you always have a fresh dollop ready for your favorite seafood dishes. Here are five tips to help you maintain the freshness of your tartar sauce:

1. Check the Expiration Date

Before purchasing or using your tartar sauce, always check the expiration date. Store-bought tartar sauce will usually have a printed date on the packaging, while homemade sauce should be consumed within a week or two.

2. Keep Tartar Sauce in the Refrigerator

Tartar sauce should always be stored in the refrigerator, preferably at a temperature between 35°F and 40°F. This helps to preserve the texture and flavor while inhibiting bacterial growth.

3. Use an Airtight Container

Storing tartar sauce in an airtight container is essential for maintaining its freshness. It keeps out any contaminants and keeps the sauce from absorbing any odors from other foods in the refrigerator.

4. Cleanliness Matters

When dipping into your tartar sauce, always use a clean utensil. Introducing contaminants can cause the sauce to spoil more quickly and affect its quality.

5. Freeze It for Long-term Storage

If you don’t think you’ll use your tartar sauce within its shelf life, consider freezing it. Place the sauce in an airtight container or freezer-safe bag and store it in the freezer for up to 3-4 months. Thaw it in the refrigerator when you’re ready to use it.

Easy-To-Make Tartar Sauce Recipes

Easy-to-make Tartar Sauce Recipes

1. Traditional Homemade Tartar Sauce

  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped dill pickles
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped capers
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh parsley
  • 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
  • 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
  • Salt and pepper, to taste

Combine all ingredients in a bowl and mix well. Adjust seasonings to taste. Refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving to allow flavors to blend.

2. Healthy Alternative: Greek Yogurt Tartar Sauce

  • 1 cup Greek yogurt
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped dill pickles
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped capers
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh parsley
  • 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
  • 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
  • Salt and pepper, to taste

Combine all ingredients in a bowl, mixing well. Adjust seasonings to taste. Refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving to allow flavors to blend. This version offers fewer calories and less fat while still maintaining a creamy texture and delicious taste.

3. Daring Twist: Spicy Chipotle Tartar Sauce

  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped dill pickles
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped capers
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh parsley
  • 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
  • 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
  • 1 tablespoon adobo sauce (from a can of chipotle peppers in adobo)
  • Salt and pepper, to taste

Combine all ingredients in a bowl, mixing well. Adjust seasonings to taste. Refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving to allow flavors to blend. This spicy tartar sauce can add a delicious kick to your seafood dishes.

The Impact of Reviews and Ratings on Choosing the Best Tartar Sauce Brand

The Impact of Reviews and Ratings on Choosing the Best Tartar Sauce Brand

Why Reviews and Rating Matter

When searching for the ultimate tartar sauce to complement your favorite seafood dishes, browsing through reviews and ratings by other consumers can be incredibly helpful. Customer feedback is an essential tool, as it provides you with real-life experiences and opinions about a product. By examining what others have to say, you can make informed decisions about which brand will suit your taste buds best.

Sorting Through the Sea of Reviews

With so many reviews available online, it can be challenging to determine which ones are truly helpful for evaluating the best tartar sauce brand. Therefore, it’s important to identify trusted sources of product reviews – such as established food blogs, magazines, or review-based websites displaying verified purchases.

Here are a few tips for making the most of your review search:

  • Look for patterns in the reviews. If multiple customers are raving about specific aspects of a tartar sauce brand, or pinpointing negative attributes, take note of these trends.
  • Pay attention to comments about flavor, texture, and packaging – these factors can immensely impact your tartar sauce experience.
  • Be cautious of overly positive or negative reviews that seem inauthentic; an overly gushing review or an excessively scathing criticism might indicate hidden agendas.

Importance of Customer Ratings

Customer ratings are another essential aspect to consider when searching for the best tartar sauce brand. Usually represented in the form of stars, these ratings provide a quick snapshot of a product’s overall satisfaction level among customers. Brands with higher average star ratings indicate a greater likelihood that the tartar sauce has met or exceeded the expectations of numerous customers.

Comparing Brands Consistently

When browsing through reviews and ratings, make sure to keep comparisons consistent. If you’re researching different sources, pay attention to how each source tends to rate products; some websites might have a more demanding rating system than others, so a product’s average rating can be skewed one way or another.

As you navigate the ocean of tartar sauce options, gathering and analyzing customer reviews and ratings can be an essential tool in determining the best brand for you. Armed with this knowledge, you’ll be able to make a well-informed choice for your future seafood feasts. Simply put, the reviews and ratings are crucial in guiding you toward the best tartar sauce brand that will suit your culinary needs.

Also Read: Best Chipotle Sauces

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main ingredients in tartar sauce?

Tartar sauce typically consists of mayonnaise, pickles or relish, capers, lemon juice, and various herbs and spices like dill, parsley, or tarragon.

Can tartar sauce be used for dishes other than seafood?

Yes, tartar sauce can be used as a dipping sauce for various appetizers like fried vegetables, or as a condiment for sandwiches and burgers, providing a tangy twist to traditional dishes.

Is tartar sauce suitable for vegetarians?

Most tartar sauces are suitable for vegetarians since they do not contain any meat products. However, it is always advised to check the label for specific brand ingredients.

What is the difference between cocktail sauce and tartar sauce?

Cocktail sauce is a tomato-based condiment that is typically spicier and contains horseradish, while tartar sauce is mayonnaise-based with a tangier and milder flavor profile.

How long is the shelf-life of an unopened store-bought tartar sauce?

Unopened store-bought tartar sauce generally lasts up to 6-12 months past the printed date, provided it is stored in a cool, dry place.

Is it safe to consume expired tartar sauce?

While consuming any expired food product is not recommended, if the tartar sauce has been properly stored, it may still be safe to consume past the expiration date; however, the quality and flavor may have diminished.

Can tartar sauce be refrigerated after opening?

Yes, it is highly recommended to refrigerate tartar sauce after opening. Properly sealed and refrigerated, tartar sauce should be safe for consumption for 6-9 months.

What are some healthy alternatives to tartar sauce?

Some healthy alternatives to traditional tartar sauce include making your own with Greek yogurt or using mashed avocado as the base.

Does tartar sauce contain gluten?

While the main ingredients in tartar sauce are generally gluten-free, some store-bought brands may contain additives that contain gluten. If gluten is a concern, it’s crucial to look for “gluten-free” labels or choose certified gluten-free brands.

Can tartar sauce be frozen to prolong its shelf life?

Although freezing is not typically recommended for mayonnaise-based products due to their tendency to separate and become watery when thawed, you can still freeze tartar sauce if necessary. If you decide to freeze it, use an airtight container and consume the sauce within a month of thawing.


After exploring the multitude of options and flavors available in the world of tartar sauces, it’s clear that the best tartar sauce brand is ultimately a personal choice based on your tastes and the dishes you love. From classic options like Kraft and McCormick to Louisiana-inspired selections and gourmet brands like Norman Bishop, there’s truly something for everyone.

I encourage you to embark on your own flavorful voyage, trying out different brands and experimenting with various pairings to find the tartar sauce that truly elevates your dining experiences. Bon appétit, and happy tartar sauce tasting!

Food Lover and Storyteller ????️✨ With a fork in one hand and a pen in the other, Shivani brings her culinary adventures to life through evocative words and tantalizing tastes. Her love for food knows no bounds, and she's on a mission to share the magic of flavors with fellow enthusiasts.
Related Articles from the same category:
This is a blog for Travellers & Travel Lovers
Copyright 2023 - All Rights Reserved.